Thanks for the responses. I find HOTW to be a remarkable blend. I can indeed detect the perique, but it comes across as a subtle tang. Any more of a perique presence gets uncomfortable for me. Sounds like I would enjoy OG, too. All the good vendors seem to be out of it!
I am nearly out of HOTW. I really enjoyed this tobacco once it aged a bit. It has all the perique I can handle (I'm very sensitive to perique, and do not usually care for it unless it is used as a light condiment). How does the flavor of OG compare to HOTW? Is the perique more noticeable?
Huge thumbs up for Uhle's tobaccos. I've tried Perfection Plug, #00, #300, #44, Black Stoker, and Crushed White Burley. 00 and PP are my favorites.
Pity about the excessive tax for WI residents. I imagine this kills in-state sales.
Nicely put, coalsmoke. I just blew through a bag of McClelland red Virginia cake (#5100). After a year or so of serious pipe smoking, I finally caught on to what simple VAs like this had to offer. I didn't have to try too hard to discern flavors or get too cerebral about something that was meant...
I've found myself adhering to the following routine:
1. Burley in the AM (Classic Burley Kake, Storm Front, various burleys from Uhles).
2. Virginia in the PM (McClelland 5100, HOTW).
I've put away (for now) the few challenging tobaccos I have. Heavy perique blends are out, as are spicy...
Your father was Frank Fallon?!?!?! I grew up hearing his voice. My father took me to my first Baylor game in the early 70's, and your dad was still announcing games when I was in school. I'm sure we have some mutual friends and acquaintances in Waco. I appreciate the good work you do with the...
Hi Pipestud. I see you reside in Waco, TX. I lived there as a young lad and returned for both my BA and MA (Baylor). I get back to Texas to visit my parents whenever I can afford to bring the whole family. Good to see another Texan, and Wacoan for that matter!
I love nutty, oat-like flavors. So it's burely for me in the morning. Today I had a blend of 1/2 Carter Hall and 1/2 PS Cube Cut. The latter has always been a bit bitey for me, even when blended. So it may be time to order some burelys from Uhle's.
P&C's University Student is a great second...
A few other posters recommended Uhle's Burleys. And--if you like Burley--they're terrific. Blend 00 and Perfection Plug Burley might be the best I've had. Sterling's Double Eagle is great, too. But as I recall it was a bit sweet for me.
Oh--let me revise my previous statement about the best...
I wasn't wild about the loose cut, although I've been told the flake is better. As far as vanilla aromatics go, I do like McClelland's Vanilla Black Cavendish. Has anyone had chance to compare this with the MacBaren (the flake)?
Been a while since I've posted. Good to read posts from familiar folks.
Some time ago I tried my first English blend: FMOTT. I simply could not adapt to the latakia. I really, really tried. I won't say what sort of associations I was (involuntarily) making with this particular blend. Please...
A few years ago I came into possession of my dear uncle's modest pipe collection. Among them are several Dunhills from the 70s and 80s. One in particular feature that is a mystery to me is the indented bowl. Pics with markings are included here. I would appreciate any insight as to the...
OK. I ordered 4 ounces of SF, and I'm smoking my first bowl. I should have ordered more. It smells and tastes exactly as advertized: quality cube cut burley with cigar leaf (the latter being pretty mild, but certainly noticeable). As you can image, it is a perfect mix of sweet and smokey...
Thanks for the suggestions. I've ordered McL. 5100, and I'll be trying MB V#1. I think my standard has become FVF, and I'd love to find an inexpensive and accessible version of this in bulk form.
Like others, I've had PS cube cut. I *love* the smell and flavor, but it bites like hell. I like to mix it with some Carter Hall for a good, less bitey codger experience.
While I've been a serious pipe smoker for only 7 months now, I've drawn the following conclusions:
1. I just can't enjoy latakia blends. I can't, I can't, I can't. I've tried. But the dark side just has no appeal for me.
2. American style Burleys are awesome, and I was stupid to scoff at...