I don't mind opinions. The hardest thing I experience in pipe smoking is figuring out what blend or genre to dedicate a pipe. I have a lot of estate pipes that I cleaned just waiting on me to figure out what to smoke in them. I'm obviously very picky about that.
Much of the problem is that these pipes came to me years after I had matched pipes to blends. As I noted, I have six pipes dedicated to Dunhill Elizabethan Match, and I try to rotate them depending on my mood, so why add another pipe to that scenario? And there are some blends that I like that I only enjoy in smaller bowls.
I have plenty of pipes dedicated to English blends so I don't need to add to that genre. Same goes for aromatics.
The old pipes, pre-1950s, I prefer untopped blends so I can take advantage of what old wood brings to my smoking experience. That greatly narrows the field for choices.
Here are two examples of bigger pipes that I want to smoke, but can't decide what to dedicate them to.
Peterson Irish Whiskey XL90.
View attachment 325666
This Pierluigi is a big one. There's not many blends I want to smoke for that long a period, which greatly limits my choices.
View attachment 325667
And I have several Ardors and Rinaldos that I inherited that I don't smoke because they are giant size. Never smoked the middle one, but the other two are among the best smokers I have, too. I smoked vintage Three Nuns in that last Ardor, and it was the best it ever tasted, but it took almost two hours to do it. That's a long time for me with any blend, even VaPer Three Nuns.
View attachment 325669
View attachment 325670
View attachment 325671