I'm still chasing the pipe tobacco aroma that I remember from my grandfather in the early 90's, and a handful of other times that I smelled pipe tobacco up until maybe the early 2000's. My grandfather didn't smoke a pipe for very long before he switched to stinky cigars, probably too much of a fuss for him. Knowing him, he smoked whatever they had at the pharmacy down the hill. Which in the 90's, still had a wall display of Dr Grabows behind the counter. I always assumed it was Captain Black because of the popularity, but after trying them myself, it definitely wasn't Regular or Royal. Maybe it was cherry, because I remember it as a very sweet smell.