H.R. 2339
- Thread starter smokeyweb
- Start date
- Status
Hard to answer because there is a lot of process left. The Senate still has to draft and pass a companion bill, both in committees and the entire body, then the two houses have to draft, in a joint committee, a compromise bill. That bill would then have to pass both bodies again and then be signed into law by President.
Given that most Republicans are speaking against the bill, a broad assumption is that the Republican-majority Senate would either fail to proceed with the bill or make significant amendments to it, whether due to partisan politics or legitimate issues with the bill's content.
They won't notice they are being controlled because they will all be stoned with the pot they bought ONLINE!
According to “Cigar Authority” it sounds like the OMB opposes this bill as it is currently written, and the President’s top advisors would urge him to veto the bill if it does pass.
The Bill has not passed -yet. The accurate state of play can be found in the link to a Politico article I posted late yesterday afternoon, and has also been accurately noted in even earlier posts. Only the Rule passed, 210-200, which is an indication that the Democrats whip count was short yesterday. There are Congresscritters on both sides of the aisle who, when their party is in the majority, will never vote against a Rule (as my retired GOP Congressman said when they were in the majority “Rules are how we run the place”) but reserve the right to vote against the underlying bill on a roll call on final passage. The Republican minority was unanimous in voting against the rule, which is typical.
Yikes but
maybe by next year if it were to pass....
This just in from the J.C. Newman newsletter -- don't know yet how pipe tobacco might be affected.
U.S. House of Representatives Votes to Provide Relief for Premium Cigars
Bill would exempt premium cigars from substantial equivalency
Today, the U.S. House of Representatives passed H.R. 2339, the Reversing the Youth Tobacco Epidemic Act. In addition to addressing youth use of tobacco products, the bill exempts premium cigars both from premarket review and from a new ban on online sales of tobacco products.
“Although it is not perfect, this is a historic bill and a huge step forward for the premium cigar industry,” said Drew Newman, general counsel of J.C. Newman Cigar Co., America’s oldest family-owned premium cigar company. “For the first time, the U.S. House of Representatives has recognized that premium cigars are unique, are not used by children, and should be exempt from unnecessary regulation.”
Section 108 of the bill would exempt premium cigars from the onerous and expensive premarket review process that would require J.C. Newman to demonstrate that natural, handcrafted premium cigars rolled today are “substantially equivalent” to ones rolled 13 years ago. Section 104 would exempt premium cigars from a new ban on mail order sales of tobacco products.
“The passage of H.R. 2339 is a clear signal to the U.S. Senate, White House, and FDA that premium cigars are different and should not be treated the same as cigarettes or vapes,” said Newman. “We are very grateful for the leadership of Congresswomen Kathy Castor and Donna Shalala for their outstanding efforts in working to save Florida’s historic premium cigar industry by including relief in this bill.”
Today’s vote follows FDA’s declaration last month that premium cigars are its “lowest priority . . . given what FDA understands to be their comparatively lower youth usage rates.”
Despite the helpful provisions above, the bill is not perfect and should be improved. Specifically, the bill’s definition of premium cigar includes a minimum retail price of $12 per cigar. FDA data show that fewer than 25% of all premium cigars sold would meet this threshold. Because state cigar taxes vary widely and manufacturers do not control retail prices, a minimum retail price of any amount does not make sense and is likely unenforceable. Similarly, the bill would subject premium cigars to the existing restrictions on cigarette advertising and marketing. This would make it illegal to have branded ashtrays, lighters, or shirts; gifts with purchase; or sponsored events such as cigar festivals.
“The bill’s minimum price and advertising and marketing restrictions would severely harm the premium cigar industry,” said Newman. “It is important to remember that this bill is not final. Today’s vote in the House is a step forward. As the bill moves to the Senate, we look forward to working to improve this legislation and remove those and other restrictions for premium cigars.”
U.S. House of Representatives Votes to Provide Relief for Premium Cigars
Bill would exempt premium cigars from substantial equivalency
Today, the U.S. House of Representatives passed H.R. 2339, the Reversing the Youth Tobacco Epidemic Act. In addition to addressing youth use of tobacco products, the bill exempts premium cigars both from premarket review and from a new ban on online sales of tobacco products.
“Although it is not perfect, this is a historic bill and a huge step forward for the premium cigar industry,” said Drew Newman, general counsel of J.C. Newman Cigar Co., America’s oldest family-owned premium cigar company. “For the first time, the U.S. House of Representatives has recognized that premium cigars are unique, are not used by children, and should be exempt from unnecessary regulation.”
Section 108 of the bill would exempt premium cigars from the onerous and expensive premarket review process that would require J.C. Newman to demonstrate that natural, handcrafted premium cigars rolled today are “substantially equivalent” to ones rolled 13 years ago. Section 104 would exempt premium cigars from a new ban on mail order sales of tobacco products.
“The passage of H.R. 2339 is a clear signal to the U.S. Senate, White House, and FDA that premium cigars are different and should not be treated the same as cigarettes or vapes,” said Newman. “We are very grateful for the leadership of Congresswomen Kathy Castor and Donna Shalala for their outstanding efforts in working to save Florida’s historic premium cigar industry by including relief in this bill.”
Today’s vote follows FDA’s declaration last month that premium cigars are its “lowest priority . . . given what FDA understands to be their comparatively lower youth usage rates.”
Despite the helpful provisions above, the bill is not perfect and should be improved. Specifically, the bill’s definition of premium cigar includes a minimum retail price of $12 per cigar. FDA data show that fewer than 25% of all premium cigars sold would meet this threshold. Because state cigar taxes vary widely and manufacturers do not control retail prices, a minimum retail price of any amount does not make sense and is likely unenforceable. Similarly, the bill would subject premium cigars to the existing restrictions on cigarette advertising and marketing. This would make it illegal to have branded ashtrays, lighters, or shirts; gifts with purchase; or sponsored events such as cigar festivals.
“The bill’s minimum price and advertising and marketing restrictions would severely harm the premium cigar industry,” said Newman. “It is important to remember that this bill is not final. Today’s vote in the House is a step forward. As the bill moves to the Senate, we look forward to working to improve this legislation and remove those and other restrictions for premium cigars.”
Cigar companies have the lobbyists and attorneys to keep the FDA at bay. Pipe mfgs are dumb asses and are going to get screwed.
Just in case I wake up one day and the forum is gone, it's been nice chattin' with you all.
Support your local B&M's and your pipe shows!
LA is now a pipe tobacco desert. Damned glad I cellared when I did.
I wouldn't go spending any big money on high priced pipes unless you're looking to own a $1500 doorstop in a few years.
LA is now a pipe tobacco desert. Damned glad I cellared when I did.
I wouldn't go spending any big money on high priced pipes unless you're looking to own a $1500 doorstop in a few years.
I was thinking today, in 5 years would I be willing to spend $50 on some Castello pipes....
You can always join my IRC channel. Let's trade there!
Man, I don’t know what I’m gonna do if online pipe tobacco sales really get shit canned. The nearest B&M with any real selection is like 1.5 hrs away and pretty darn expensive. Bummed I didn’t get into pipe smoking sooner and give myself more time to cellar.
- Status