And also reds that he doesn’t know are reds. Without problem.
Allergic To Red Virginia
- Thread starter BROBS
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
I think the deep question, a subject for significant meditation by every participant, is whether participating in this thread has enriched your life and made you a better human being.
.gif)
Good discussion going on guys. I have a few books on tobacco at home, but I am at work so I can't go too in depth knowledgeably, but I'll throw this bit of info out there.
__________________
Virginia Tobacco
Virginias are the king of tobaccos and the very crop our country was built on. As you may have already deduced from the name, it was originally grown in well-known VA Plantations. Today, Virginia tobaccos are grown not only in VA but also eastern NC, northeastern SC, and, indeed, around the world. The term "Old Belt" is an appellation and refers to Virginias grown in VA and NC.
Virginias are primarily classified by their color, and while the exact nuance of hue lends itself to a vast array of categorizations, think "red" and "bright". The relative location of a given leaf on its stalk is what ultimately determines its color; the brights come from the middle of the stalk, and the reds originate from higher up to the tips. While all Virginias are sweet, the further a leaf moves toward the lighter side of the color spectrum, the sweeter it becomes, but along with that sweetness comes additional acidity and hints of citrus-like tartness. As we move towards progressively darkening colors, along with an increasing depth of flavor comes a taste that shifts to something akin to baking bread.
______________________________________
The highlighted portion (Blue text) is the part that I'm going to refer to.
Since Red Virginias have a higher acidity content than the darker Virginias, maybe the acidity is what some people are allergic to. Not the plant itself per se, but the acidity that is found in that part of the plant. So in essence, they may be allergic to Red Virginias not because of the plant, but because of the acids that are IN that part of the plant makes them allergic to that specific part of the plant.
Full Disclaimer: I am not an allergy doctor. Heck I'm not a doctor of any type.
Although I do play one at home sometimes ?.
__________________
Virginia Tobacco
Virginias are the king of tobaccos and the very crop our country was built on. As you may have already deduced from the name, it was originally grown in well-known VA Plantations. Today, Virginia tobaccos are grown not only in VA but also eastern NC, northeastern SC, and, indeed, around the world. The term "Old Belt" is an appellation and refers to Virginias grown in VA and NC.
Virginias are primarily classified by their color, and while the exact nuance of hue lends itself to a vast array of categorizations, think "red" and "bright". The relative location of a given leaf on its stalk is what ultimately determines its color; the brights come from the middle of the stalk, and the reds originate from higher up to the tips. While all Virginias are sweet, the further a leaf moves toward the lighter side of the color spectrum, the sweeter it becomes, but along with that sweetness comes additional acidity and hints of citrus-like tartness. As we move towards progressively darkening colors, along with an increasing depth of flavor comes a taste that shifts to something akin to baking bread.
______________________________________
The highlighted portion (Blue text) is the part that I'm going to refer to.
Since Red Virginias have a higher acidity content than the darker Virginias, maybe the acidity is what some people are allergic to. Not the plant itself per se, but the acidity that is found in that part of the plant. So in essence, they may be allergic to Red Virginias not because of the plant, but because of the acids that are IN that part of the plant makes them allergic to that specific part of the plant.
Full Disclaimer: I am not an allergy doctor. Heck I'm not a doctor of any type.
Although I do play one at home sometimes ?.
If that were the case then if someone was “allergic” to red VA they would be incredibly so to brightleaf.
In the case of orange juice I would first suspect an issue with acidity as it is much more common.
On the other hand, if other citrus juices never caused any issues further investigation might be warranted.
That’s what’s going on. I mean, maybe not THAT specifically, but it’s likely a component of the leaf that’s present in reds and not in others.
If you’re allergic to garlic and I serve you spaghetti without garlic, you’ll likely not have a reaction. However, if I serve you spaghetti with garlic, you’ll probably be pissed.
Both dishes were spaghetti, but one component being present, or not, caused an issue. This isn’t impossible with plants, either, based on several variables - most are environmental in nature.
True. Just playing devils advocate.
I know how we may be able to come to a conclusion. I will sacrifice my mouth and health for the betterment of the site and this debatable question.
Everyone please send me all of your Virginia tobacco blends so that I can smoke them and do a serious scientific study on the allergic reactions of Virginia tobacco blends and their components. This is a free study. The only cost to you will be shipping me the tobacco. Everyone will be fully credited for their participation in this study.
Contact me now!
After we solve this allergy conundrum ...let’s get on to COVID and really make an impact?!?
️
️
After we solve this allergy conundrum ...let’s get on to COVID and really make an impact?!?
Now that's a three pipe problem.
I was under the impression Red Virginia was a marketing term..
It basically is. At what point on the plant is the separation between red and bright leaf?
And let me be clear: I’m not saying people don’t have some type of reaction to it... I’m just saying that I don’t believe “allergy” to be the correct term.
"red virginia" is just one of the roughly 150 different USDA grades of flue cured leaf. The slightly higher than average sugar content caramelizes at the higher temperatures of the curing process, resulting in the mahogany coloring.
It can happen accidentally or be tried for. They are totally a thing, and not just marketing.
It can happen accidentally or be tried for. They are totally a thing, and not just marketing.
Sounds like a grading system for marketing tobacco to me..
It's a grading system for bringing tobacco to market. Which is semantically close, but not in actual practice.
@cigrmaster has pretty damn fine taste in blends & pipes if yas ask me...just saying.
Maybe what @cigrmaster is referring in past threads is that as long as he’s not choochin away on McCranies Red ? he’s alright??
️
I have some issues with Red Va dominated blends from McClelland, C&D, and Mac Baren, such as HH Pure Virginia. It is no allergy, but I am the sensitive type. .—.
However, why are we assuming that all red VA leaf produced around the world is the same. I seem to do better with non-American VA leaf, though I am fine American red leaf mixed in with other tobaccos.
However, why are we assuming that all red VA leaf produced around the world is the same. I seem to do better with non-American VA leaf, though I am fine American red leaf mixed in with other tobaccos.
- Status