What Cigar are You Smoking? 2024

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

jbfrady

Part of the Furniture Now
Jul 27, 2023
698
2,927
South Carolina
Classic Oliva, enjoyed in the classiest joint I've ever visited: Fellaship ATL. Located in downtown Atlanta, featuring a full cocktail bar with all sorts of food and a quaint humidor that sticks all the basic necessities, this place is owned by NFL legend Cam Newton. I didn't realize I was visiting on the same day as a Falcons home game, so the whole vicinity was overflowing and parking was an absolute bitch, but a stop at this place made it all worthwhile.
20241103_133806.jpg
20241103_135851.jpg
20241103_133815.jpg
 

Peter Turbo

Lifer
Oct 18, 2021
1,429
11,128
CT, USA
Classic Oliva, enjoyed in the classiest joint I've ever visited: Fellaship ATL. Located in downtown Atlanta, featuring a full cocktail bar with all sorts of food and a quaint humidor that sticks all the basic necessities, this place is owned by NFL legend Cam Newton. I didn't realize I was visiting on the same day as a Falcons home game, so the whole vicinity was overflowing and parking was an absolute bitch, but a stop at this place made it all worthwhile.
View attachment 346630
View attachment 346628
View attachment 346629
Damn that place looks legit!
 

pantsBoots

Lifer
Jul 21, 2020
2,349
8,908
Another Xhaxhi Bobi El Licenciado while doing some of the year-end seed planting. These cigars are freaking nice - everything I love in Dominican tobacco plus a twist from the Peruvian leaf. I put a box away on a hunch that they'll be better in a couple years.
IMG_20241104_151327771.jpg
 

pantsBoots

Lifer
Jul 21, 2020
2,349
8,908
Crusty old Rafael Gonzalez Panetelas I've had for at least 10 years. It's bounced around the humidor for long enough - time to put it out of its misery.

IMG_20241104_190411139.jpg

Discontinued for some time now, the RGP was never a great cigar and rarely a bad cigar, unless it was plugged. Being a true Havana Cuban sandwich cigar (made with short and medium filler), the draw is tight, but entirely manageable.

Dry draws taste of oatmeal, hickory wood, and bitter espresso.
1st third - sweet & exotic woodiness, bitter latte, orange dark chocolate, mineral-laden Cuban earth, and a little slap and tickle from black pepper.
2nd third - big notes of hickory wood finished with a little nougat, faint cinnamon & sugar, the latte is now cafe au lait in that it is sweeter and hides the pepper, tastes quite a bit like a Padron 1964, developing notes of oatmeal with a brandy-like finish.
3rd third - bitter coffee, charred oak casks (slight brandy or whiskey finish), toast made from dark bread, and finally loads of chocolate cake and Tootsie rolls - a Rafael Gonzalez hallmark.

The above is honestly an oversimplification. I was paying attention to the smoke and keeping notes, and was amazed at how each note came and went over the course of numerous puffs, sometimes complementing other flavors, and other times drowning them out entirely. It was such a cheap cigar (this came from a box that cost $40-50), and other than a claro-colored sample in the same humidor, there are no more to be had without opening your wallet wide. Shame.
 
Crusty old Rafael Gonzalez Panetelas I've had for at least 10 years. It's bounced around the humidor for long enough - time to put it out of its misery.

View attachment 346836

Discontinued for some time now, the RGP was never a great cigar and rarely a bad cigar, unless it was plugged. Being a true Havana Cuban sandwich cigar (made with short and medium filler), the draw is tight, but entirely manageable.

Dry draws taste of oatmeal, hickory wood, and bitter espresso.
1st third - sweet & exotic woodiness, bitter latte, orange dark chocolate, mineral-laden Cuban earth, and a little slap and tickle from black pepper.
2nd third - big notes of hickory wood finished with a little nougat, faint cinnamon & sugar, the latte is now cafe au lait in that it is sweeter and hides the pepper, tastes quite a bit like a Padron 1964, developing notes of oatmeal with a brandy-like finish.
3rd third - bitter coffee, charred oak casks (slight brandy or whiskey finish), toast made from dark bread, and finally loads of chocolate cake and Tootsie rolls - a Rafael Gonzalez hallmark.

The above is honestly an oversimplification. I was paying attention to the smoke and keeping notes, and was amazed at how each note came and went over the course of numerous puffs, sometimes complementing other flavors, and other times drowning them out entirely. It was such a cheap cigar (this came from a box that cost $40-50), and other than a claro-colored sample in the same humidor, there are no more to be had without opening your wallet wide. Shame.
I think I bought this when I visited Canada last year. I liked them