I like it! A good friend, who has no connection to tobacco, bought it for me last year. I use it all the time as my primary tray.I have the same ashtray and thoroughly enjoy it. It's great for setting down a pipe when I get interrupted while also holding a lighter and tamper when on the move.
I also use a tobacco caddy when I may have time for a second pipe and want to be on the porch instead of in the garage.
View attachment 191675