I've had the Gawith Hoggarth Black Cherry & Cherry Vanilla; I think they both in my clay pipes but I like the Cherry Vanilla most. I especially enjoyed it in my clay when I went to see Lace Wars & the Sealed Knot re-enactments.It’s 2/3 Kendal Gold Vanilla shag and 1/3 Dark Birdseye both Gawith&Hoggarth!