fitzy, oh yes, roth was something of a Forums all-star. He knew his pipes, tobacco, pipe history, and more. He was an extra smart edgy guy who managed to get in (if I remember) about 17K posts before his competitive nature finally crossed wires with management here. When he wasn't being combative, he was so knowledgable and interesting, and had various points of view that were contrarian but worthwhile. I didn't always agree with him, but I often learned something from him. And quite often I did agree with him. He and I shared a no-ream (just wipe out the pipe after smokes) philosophy, among others. His good posts crop up regularly when people exhume some of the oldies, and his name sneaks into those old-time discussion.