I'll stand up for Greenwich Village as it has been until very recently. True, true, plenty of young artists going nowhere, phonies, poseurs, and tourists. It was also a unique village in the midst of a vast city where a lot of greatly talented people made their mark. I say this because my wife lived and worked there for decades. I also say that as someone who has never lived in a romanticized place -- a suburb of Chicago which was not Chicago, some state university campuses not in the Ivy League, Neosho Missouri, and mid-sized cities hither and yon. So I know a hawk from a hand saw in terms of seeing where I am. My wife grew up in a tiny remote town in farm country in Missouri, so she also had a grounded perspective, and a lot of friends who once lived in Greenwich Village.