Lane 1 Q
- Thread starter Dirty D
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
1Q is bland to me, but I don't notice the chemicals. I puzzle over the fact that it is one of Lane's best sellers, renamed and sold by many pipe shops as one of their house blends. It is safe and non-threatening for new smokers, so it's said, but it must have many regular customers to keep selling so well. It's a mystery, and a revenue stream for Lane.
You know, everything is subjective and our bodies react differently to variable components. I find that 1Q, for me at least doesn't have the chemical putrid taste that Captain Black has and far less moist. I bought 8oz this year and stored it up. I can smoke multiple bowls of this in a row and I generally don't smoke aromatics. Is it a powerhouse tobacco? No, but it has a cult following and regardless of its reputation, it's one of the better aromatics I've smoked.
I usually mix 1-Q with BCA 50/50, then add a pinch of bright Virgina flakes to dry it a bit and enhance burn rate. The BCA ramps up the flavor and depth. The ribbon cut of 1-Q burns consistently, but smoked straight it can have a little bite and burn hot. The addition of BCA cools it down and eliminates any bite. Works for me.
I started off smoking aromatics, 1Q, Boswells, and a few others mentioned here but haven't smoked one in a couple years. Last time I smoked an aromatic was Sleepy Hollow and it was goopy and wet but did have good flavor that went away pretty quickly. just not my cup of tea and will stick with Va and VaPers.
I'll say it. I love 1Q from Lane. Like nearly every aromatic it needs a good sit out prior to smoking but I find delightful with zero chemical notes. Everyone should smoke what works for them and in good company (unless you'd rather smoke alone in which case refer to the what works for you rule)
I've returned to 1-q a couple of times to see if i'm missing anything. Haven't figured it out yet lol.
Do you work in a chemical factory or some otherwise strongly scented environment?
I have about 4 oz of it that’s probably 15 yrs old. Just revanilla’d it. I keep it for guests in case anyone wants a bland one dimensional bowl of propylene glycol
Recently I bought a pound of 1Q & I quite like it also.
It's not at all moist, burns well & does not bite [to which I seem to be susceptible]
I'm not sure what others mean by chemical notes either.
1Q is a nice mild aromatic that's not heavily topped.
Wonder if there's a variation between batches or source of purchase?
Mine was bulk from 4noggins if that makes any difference.
I always find it amusing when people dislike 1Q so much that it almost seems that they were physically assaulted by the tobacco. 
Some people like to gin up the drama, I guess.? I'm not quite sure what people are expecting. It's just a typical vanilla cased blond and black cavendish, nothing more, nothing less. But hey, to each his own.
I started smoking 1Q under it's various brick and mortar names 40 years ago and in that time, I have found a few vanilla aros that could be considered better but not so much better that they would stop me from smoking 1Q. The biggest problem with 1Q that I have found is that it's a somewhat mild or even bland smoke, but on the other hand it's always consistant and certainly not offensive in anyway. Chemical wise...I have found that it's no more chemically ladden than any other bulk aro and less so than many others.
Nowadays I don't smoke a lot of aromatic tobacco, but when I do, one of my go to aros is still 1Q. Only now I usually mix it with equal parts of BAC.
Some people like to gin up the drama, I guess.? I'm not quite sure what people are expecting. It's just a typical vanilla cased blond and black cavendish, nothing more, nothing less. But hey, to each his own.I started smoking 1Q under it's various brick and mortar names 40 years ago and in that time, I have found a few vanilla aros that could be considered better but not so much better that they would stop me from smoking 1Q. The biggest problem with 1Q that I have found is that it's a somewhat mild or even bland smoke, but on the other hand it's always consistant and certainly not offensive in anyway. Chemical wise...I have found that it's no more chemically ladden than any other bulk aro and less so than many others.
Nowadays I don't smoke a lot of aromatic tobacco, but when I do, one of my go to aros is still 1Q. Only now I usually mix it with equal parts of BAC.
Yeah it’s not THAT bad. To me it’s just kinda bland and it bites me but I think the room note is nice and it makes my car smell like cookies.I always find it amusing when people dislike 1Q so much that it almost seems that they were physically assaulted by the tobacco.
I started smoking 1Q under it's various brick and mortar names 40 years ago and in that time, I have found a few vanilla aros that could be considered better but not so much better that they would stop me from smoking 1Q. The biggest problem with 1Q that I have found is that it's a somewhat mild or even bland smoke, but on the other hand it's always consistant and certainly not offensive in anyway. Chemical wise...I have found that it's no more chemically ladden than any other bulk aro and less so than many others.
Nowadays I don't smoke a lot of aromatic tobacco, but when I do, one of my go to aros is still 1Q. Only now I usually mix it with equal parts of BAC.
I prefer natural tobacco flavours these days, but I didn't have any problem with the odd bowl a few times. It's not terribly offensive
I'm sorry to hear that...Hopefully the swelling will go down in time for the prom.
Usually the swelling goes down...after prom...
As a dessert replacement I’ll smoke 1Q / BCA 50/50. It’s sweet as anything, and no real nicotine or much tobacco flavour at all. It’s not often, but it hits the spot maybe once a month.
seriously it's gotta be the way cilantro is. Where some people really sense one thing where other people get another taste (in cilantro some people actually taste something citrusy and nice and not that wonderful hand soap flavor). Cause if it tasted anything like it does to me people wouldn't buy it ever and wouldn't make jokes about over reacting to it. And it wouldn't be a big seller. If it smelled and tasted the same (you know the way most pipe tobaccos do imho) it would be great. But that chemical taste is terrible to some of us. Still better then Captain Black though.
Yeah, I guess I'd smoke cilantro before Craptain Black. Maybe a 50/50 of cilantro and parsley.
Then again, I'm a cilantro lover.