I thought the same thing. That had better grain than most Blue Ribands I've seen in a long time. But not $800 worth, that's for sure. The button did appear to have been buffed or sanded down.beat off is correct...
Anything over $300.00 for a Blue Riband is crazy, and it better be mint for $300.
The Cadogan era Supreme Grain I have in the classifieds has pretty similar grain, for a whole lot less money!