All this does, in my humble opinion, is prove my contention that presentation is paramount when listing on ebay. Todd does a first rate job of presentation.
Regarding the speculation here that he's doping his pipes in some way to get that shine, that's ridiculous. I can get that same level of shine with Paragon and my bare hands. It's all in the touch. Some of us got it Some of us don't.
Todd was mentored by Jeff Gracik, so no surprise his offerings look good. Careful lighting to pop contrast, and a wee bit of a contrast boost to the image. Bingo!
Rodrigo gets top prices with his minimalist approach, though the quality of his photography has gone way, way, down. But his market has been solid. Now at least, he cleans his pipes. Years ago when I occasionally bought one of his, it was filthy.