If You Had to Choose Only One Tobacco

[Mtlpiper]

This is an interesting thread to pore through.

I can honestly say that I need to smoke more blends 'properly' (like, go through full tins not just 'try occasionally') to even properly think of a halfway truthful answer.

Even then, I don't think I could come up with a single blend and be satisfied with it exclusively. Variety is the spice of life etc. etc.

I'd say Nightcap is something I always come back to - but it's an evening smoke for me. Maybe something from Germain's - either RDF or Brown Flake.

 

[boston]

Only one? 1792 probably. Glad I don't need to make that decision...

 

[k9shag]

Red Ribbon

 

[carolinasmokes]

Carter Hall

 

[newbroom]

Firedance , er storm....by Russ Oulette. I've only smoked one tin, cuz it's expensive, but it's right there with the very best I've smoked in 7 yrs.
Firestorm

 

[SlowerThanMost]

PRESBY BABY

 

[coming to_falling too]

Samuel Gawith Sam's Flake in a Mastercraft Natural bulldog

 

[jewman22]

This WAS an easy question for me to answer, had you asked before I tried Spark Plug. Now it's hard to choose between Frog on a Log and Spark Plug. Pirate Kake is a solid 3rd.

 

[judcole]

I would no more want to choose just one tobacco to smoke than I would wish to choose one food to eat.

 

[B.Lew]

Stonehenge Flake with 2 years in the can.

 

[Mark 0092]

Brown No 4 Samuel

 

[haparnold]

This is a recent change in my palate, but I’ve got to go with Haddo’s

 

[edger]

This is a recent change in my palate, but I’ve got to go with Haddo’s

And I thought you would choose Three Friars!

 

[vink]

Right now Peterson/Dunhill deluxe navy rolls...

 

[anotherbob]

Edward G Robinson. It scratches many itches and it's a blend I enjoy always. There are plenty I like more, but not so many I am always in the mood for.

 

[glub]

Capstan Blue. If a second were allowed, Escudo. Definitely my two desert island blends.

 

[hawky454]

Impossible question really, I think it would be easier to put the pipe down & smoke cigars instead.

Oh come on, Simon. You know it would be St. Bruno.

 

[tkcolo]

Solani ABF, but I've been smoking haunted bookshop all winter

 

[haparnold]

And I thought you would choose Three Friars!

I could easily have Three Friars for my only smoke, but just the last month or so Haddo’s has nudged it out.

 

[metarzan]

At this point I honestly have no idea, still haven't found what I'm searching for... At one point I might have chose Blue Mountain/Balkan Blue but that ship has sailed. I very much would like to narrow down to a Balkan, a VaPer and a satisfying Lat x-over with friendly room note. Choose one blend today at gunpoint? Shoot me!