Cornell & Diehl Folklore

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Jan 28, 2018
13,912
155,505
67
Sarasota, FL
Satisify some big customers at the expense of the many smaller customers who only want a couple of tins. I would want all my customers to have equal access. What's next 5lb bricks.

They will sell it all. No doubt. Just like Sun Bear had no meaningful limit on number of tins to purchase so alot of guys missed out. Alot of people were disappointed about that.
It's called small batch for a reason with small being the key word. Anyone that really wanted any of the small batches should have gotten some, they weren't sold out in the first hour. Anyone that didn't want it enough to put in a little extra effort didn't want it enough to justify complaining IMHO. Many companies do small batches or limited edition offerings where every customer would not be able to purchase any.
 

kschatey

Lifer
Oct 16, 2019
1,118
2,283
Ohio
Not everyone, me among them, wants a large mason jar. I prefer the tobacco split up among smaller jars. Not to mention the difficulty and added expense of shipping all those glass jars. No question, some would get broken creating a big headache on returns.
Definitely my thoughts as well, but was probably something at least considered at some point since this particular offering is part of their Small Batch releases. Regardless, a vacuum packed brick in a fancy wrap is nice and economical.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swiss Army Knife
Jan 28, 2018
13,912
155,505
67
Sarasota, FL
Satisify some big customers at the expense of the many smaller customers who only want a couple of tins. I would want all my customers to have equal access. What's next 5lb bricks.

They will sell it all. No doubt. Just like Sun Bear had no meaningful limit on number of tins to purchase so alot of guys missed out. Alot of people were disappointed about that.
If you didn't get any Sun Bear, you only have yourself to blame. Sorry. I could also make an argument that it is more important to satisfy the "big" customers. I'm guessing pipe tobacco follows the 80 20 rule where 20% of the customers represent 80% of the business. C&D runs a business, it's not a charitable organization.
 

alaskanpiper

Enabler in Chief
May 23, 2019
9,431
43,844
Alaska
I’ll miss this one as 1lb is simply way too much for a smoker like me. Smoking once a week or so I’d have to smoke this blend exclusively for years to run out.

I get that I am the minority in that tho. If I were a daily smoker i’d be all over it as I’ve enjoyed almost all the small batch offerings. 1lb is just too much to acquire for me on a blend ive never tried. Hope its great for all those who get it!
 
Jan 28, 2018
13,912
155,505
67
Sarasota, FL
Way too much for me. I'd take a tin or two but not an lb.

Another marketing blunder by C&D. It will probably sell out but if they did tins they would satisfy a lot more customers.

PASS
I have to respectfully disagree. In fact, I'd say in the past three years, C&D's marketing strategy has been significantly superior to anyone else in the industry. Given the potential deeming legislation, I think the small batch strategy has been brilliant. It draws attention to the brand and creates some excitement while alleviating any potential issues with legislation. Doesn't satisfy everyone? Tell me something that does.
 
Jan 28, 2018
13,912
155,505
67
Sarasota, FL
I’ll miss this one as 1lb is simply way too much for a smoker like me. Smoking once a week or so I’d have to smoke this blend exclusively for years to run out.

I get that I am the minority in that tho. If I were a daily smoker i’d be all over it as I’ve enjoyed almost all the small batch offerings. 1lb is just too much to acquire for me on a blend ive never tried. Hope its great for all those who get it!
Thanks for an honest assessment. There will certainly be those third party guys that buy as much as they can and will turn around and sell it in small increments.
 

kschatey

Lifer
Oct 16, 2019
1,118
2,283
Ohio
If you didn't get any Sun Bear, you only have yourself to blame. Sorry. I could also make an argument that it is more important to satisfy the "big" customers. I'm guessing pipe tobacco follows the 80 20 rule where 20% of the customers represent 80% of the business. C&D runs a business, it's not a charitable organization.
This was why I asked my follow up question to that statement as well. Even the Sun Bear Black Locust release last year seemed more available than the Sun Bear 2019 release, although in both cases I could have purchased far more than I did from multiple locations at multiple release times. That doesn't even include B&M options. I decided ow much I wanted, got it, and that was it. I completely passed on the Eight State and other Small Batch releases and later decided that I wanted a couple tins of Eight State and bought them online from P&C during another if their delayed releases. There were other Small Batches also still available after the fact that I opted out of at the time as well. To @hoosierpipeguy 's point though, if somebody wants any of these releases, it's not impossible to get them, but it may take *some* effort as they aren't just going to automatically show up in the mailbox through some magical intervention. This is not to say that I have been able to acquire every blend that I've ever wanted to try. A couple years ago I got lucky on getting a couple Esoterica offerings (Margate and Peacehaven, others sold out too fast), but others have been more elusive and that's okay. I can get them if I put in more effort and/or money, but this is not something that I am loosing any sleep over. I have plenty of awesome tobacco already and sometimes I just don't want to play the game and that's just fine with me. Maybe part of this is because I already got over all of this craziness during my rare beer trading and hunting days even before that entire thing got even more insane like it is today...
 
Jun 23, 2019
1,936
13,232
Satisify some big customers at the expense of the many smaller customers who only want a couple of tins. I would want all my customers to have equal access. What's next 5lb bricks.

They will sell it all. No doubt. Just like Sun Bear had no meaningful limit on number of tins to purchase so alot of guys missed out. Alot of people were disappointed about that.

I'm not sure what you're saying here with the "big" and "smaller" customers. Are you *just* bemoaning the 1lb packaging? Because fair enough, it's their first time doing something like that - I bet it's because on their end they can see the numbers and most people who are buying these limited Small Batches online are buying out the fully allowed daily limits. I think they're testing out if demand is truly to cellar and stock or if most people are indeed buying to flip. I think they'll find their answer after this drop.

If you're in the tobacco business, you had to have looked at the recent McClelland and Esoterica prices and thought to yourself how can I capture some of this raging demand for "premium" tobacco? I think early on with Sun Bear they were testing out their thesis and have been releasing them in larger and larger limited runs (how does that make sense?) similar to that you see with the Carolina Red Flake, there are some minor holes in their marketing narrative and when you put 2 + 2 together you'll probably understand what they're doing here.

Thanks for an honest assessment. There will certainly be those third party guys that buy as much as they can and will turn around and sell it in small increments.

I think it's the way these releases have been that are slowly making people into flippers. I myself included. The last couple of small batches I bought 1/2 tins - Eight State Burley, From Beyond I really liked, now I gotta pay north of $35 a tin if I can find some, should've just bought the max and if I didn't like it sell at anywhere from MSRP to 2-300% - but I'm asking honestly here, what a guy to do?
 

Swiss Army Knife

Can't Leave
Jul 12, 2021
459
1,349
North Carolina
I wonder if the 1lb vacuum sealed brick will make it more difficult to flip. It's obviously less sturdy long term and generally people are less excited to drop PipeStud or, gasp, 4Noggins prices on repackaged limited releases.

And I can't sympathize with anyone bemoaning the availability of a lot of these releases because they're still pretty reasonable to get. Like hoosier said: they're not selling out in hours, clearly there's not botnets buying out entire stocks in seconds. If you were going to kvetch about finding Penzance online I can appreciate the struggle, but things like C&D small batch, Sutliff or MacBaren limited releases are available.
 
Jul 26, 2021
2,412
9,781
Metro-Detroit
I’ll miss this one as 1lb is simply way too much for a smoker like me. Smoking once a week or so I’d have to smoke this blend exclusively for years to run out.

I get that I am the minority in that tho. If I were a daily smoker i’d be all over it as I’ve enjoyed almost all the small batch offerings. 1lb is just too much to acquire for me on a blend ive never tried. Hope its great for all those who get it!
Thanks for an honest assessment. There will certainly be those third party guys that buy as much as they can and will turn around and sell it in small increments.
Another option is "going in" on a pound with others.

Save on price with a manageable amount of tobacco for each person. The only issue is having to thumb wrestle over the label sticker.
 

mingc

Lifer
Jun 20, 2019
4,234
12,553
The Big Rock Candy Mountains
I suspect there are B&M's who'll be willing to break the bricks out and sell it by the oz.

I think C&D's model of selling limited availability products along with ones that are always available is a smart one. The demand whipped up the small batch releases spills over to the others. For instance, I bet it sells a lot more Bijou when folks can't get Sun Bear. And the positive impression left by high quality small batches can only raise its general reputation.
 
May 2, 2018
3,975
30,777
Bucks County, PA
Way too much for me. I'd take a tin or two but not an lb.

Another marketing blunder by C&D. It will probably sell out but if they did tins they would satisfy a lot more customers.

PASS
Marketing Blunder…yeah I guess C&D is gonna have a real hard time selling these off.? I mean we are doing a good bit of marketing for them I’d say & haven’t shut up about this business fiasco from the jump. And, because these are in limited supply…I’m gonna say they’ll sell like ?…gone in 60 minutes I should think. ?

These batch jobs are smart business & although I’m not a player with this one. I’m sure they’ll get me down the line at some point. On a side note, I just added 8oz of every C&D/GL Pease Virginia, VaPer, VaOr to my SP.com wish list cue. Every quarter I’ll add a tin to my lb order of beloved Haunted Bookshop. ?☕
 

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
44,908
117,158
Another marketing blunder by C&D.
Actually marketing at its finest. It engenders a sense of lessened availability and drives sells even higher. Plus a normal tinned small batch would be around $96 to get a pound of it when in tins. This release triggers the "I'm getting a deal!" response. I've hit my tobacco limit so none for me.
 
Jan 28, 2018
13,912
155,505
67
Sarasota, FL
I wonder if the 1lb vacuum sealed brick will make it more difficult to flip. It's obviously less sturdy long term and generally people are less excited to drop PipeStud or, gasp, 4Noggins prices on repackaged limited releases.

And I can't sympathize with anyone bemoaning the availability of a lot of these releases because they're still pretty reasonable to get. Like hoosier said: they're not selling out in hours, clearly there's not botnets buying out entire stocks in seconds. If you were going to kvetch about finding Penzance online I can appreciate the struggle, but things like C&D small batch, Sutliff or MacBaren limited releases are available.
It will to some extent because the buyer is going to have to trust the seller to actually be shipping the small batch and not some similar Sutliff bulk blend. No different than someone selling jars of Penzance. How would an inexperienced buyer know it was Dreams of Kadath or Quiet Nights instead of Penzance?
 
May 2, 2018
3,975
30,777
Bucks County, PA
It will to some extent because the buyer is going to have to trust the seller to actually be shipping the small batch and not some similar Sutliff bulk blend. No different than someone selling jars of Penzance. How would an inexperienced buyer know it was Dreams of Kadath or Quiet Nights instead of Penzance?
Yeah, someone that’d never had Penzance could easily fall for a Quiet Nights substitute. ☕
 
  • Like
Reactions: hoosierpipeguy

kschatey

Lifer
Oct 16, 2019
1,118
2,283
Ohio
There will certainly be those third party guys that buy as much as they can and will turn around and sell it in small increments.
Not worth the time and effort to do that in my opinion giving the cost of shipping materials and shipping itself these days. All the more power to them!

Previous Small Batch releases retailed for about $15 for a 2 oz tin. This is suuposedly $60 for 1 lb, so pretty much half the price. For people remotely interested in the blend, that seems more than fair and given the number of other people interested, but don't want to buy the full pound (but would apparently be more than willing to pay double for smaller tins), I seems likely that it would be easy to trade/resell if tried and not liked.
 
Jan 28, 2018
13,912
155,505
67
Sarasota, FL
Not worth the time and effort to do that in my opinion giving the cost of shipping materials and shipping itself these days. All the more power to them!

Previous Small Batch releases retailed for about $15 for a 2 oz tin. This is suuposedly $60 for 1 lb, so pretty much half the price. For people remotely interested in the blend, that seems more than fair and given the number of other people interested, but don't want to buy the full pound (but would apparently be more than willing to pay double for smaller tins), I seems likely that it would be easy to trade/resell if tried and not liked.
Certainly not worth it to me but none of what they do is worth it to me for that matter. I assume they would simply break it up and put it in mylar or zip locks to ship to their customers. Most B&M's sell their bulk blends in zip locks. I'm confident there will be people offering it in 2 or 4 ounce increments at $10 an ounce plus shipping. I'm equally confident there will be eager buyers. I would even get there will be people who will spend $60 on 8 ounces or less which seems insane when they could buy 16 for $60 upfront.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: kschatey