My vote is for Prince Albert. I've only had the newer stuff. Here's my coffee analogy:
The OCB's with more toppings are like coffee with cream and sugar, or maybe with a flavored syrup, which is fine if that's your thing.
Prince is like a very basic, roasted medium, cup of black coffee. Not fussy, but also not a lot of depth; just a touch of chocolate that seems like it's not there. Suits me fine.
Probably true of SWR non-aromatic, which I tried a dried up old bag on vacation once and threw the rest out. I also would like to try other OCB's but the drugstores out here don't stock any pipe tobacco. Most of the pipe shops hardly carry any either. I order tubs of CA and Prince, and I favor the Prince.