marine33
Look at these guys, http://www.milantobacco.com/ under their house blends. You didn't mention tongue bite, which was a problem for me when I got back into pipe smoking. It took me awhile to find aromatics that didn't torch my tongue. Everybody is different but I like Poochie's Blend and Butterberry from Milan. Boswell's has great aro's too, as you said. I like their house blend Pennsylvania Dutch Treat. I wouldn't say I have ever had an aro that actually tasted as sweet as the name implies. I guess it depends on what you are going for. Have you tried Boswell English blends? For an aro smoker, I liked Countryside. You will hear good and bad about any brand if you hear enough opinions. :O)