As for the tobacco I would have to go with Russ left overs. I forget what it’s called, but it’s all the stuff left on the table that gets thrown in a bin after orders are filled. It’s a different bowl every time.
I think Shackleton was left with wild grasses soaked in boiled pipes. I'll stick with a Missouri cob and salty dog. The cob would be easily repaired with items found on an island. And if all else failed salty dog is a great chewI'm amending my list. I want whatever Shackleton was smoking and whatever he was smoking it with.