Will The STG Market Disruption Create Opportunity For Boutique Blenders?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

36 Fresh Rossi Pipes
84 Fresh Ropp Pipes
29 Fresh Eltang Basic Pipes
3 Fresh Bill Shalosky Pipes
36 Fresh AKB Meerschaum Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

greeneyes

Lifer
Jun 5, 2018
2,290
12,668
The smartest thing the distributors could do to compensate for the loss of Sutliff blending tobaccos destined for small blenders is to negotiate the importation of bulk blending leaf from Dan/DTM and Kopp, both in Germany. Their blending leaf is exceptionally good quality, and in the case at least of Dan, already exists in bulk packaging.

The brick and mortar shops and retailers with house blends can contact their importer / distributers and request this leaf. Or they can throw up their hands and quit. Up to them.
 

jtkuga

Lurker
Dec 19, 2024
16
28
Hopefully there will be some entrepreneurs who will step up, although it may end up costing us more. I'm new to pipe smoking and know nothing of the tobacco business. But for people who like fine things, and I'd consider pipe tobacco to be among fine things like high end meat, wines, etc., there is a market. Anyone who has ever bought meat online knows you can get really good stuff. Sometimes very overpriced yes, but still very good. I recently got into Iberico Pork, google Campo Grande pork if you have any interest. It is very good, and some cuts taste more like beef than pork. But as you will see on the website, very expensive. I've read the wine industry has taken a hit this year, but the high end stuff still sells for a very high price, there is still plenty of demand for it. As I've said I know nothing of the tobacco industry so I could be completely wrong, but I guess I'm being an optimist (sort of). I do worry more about government regulations than anything else. The Weed industry seems to be thriving though...
 
  • Like
Reactions: KK9Z and suamrai61

WirelessSmoke

Starting to Get Obsessed
Jul 14, 2024
233
2,915
New England
I think it absolutely leaves some opportunity for some smaller businesses and blenders to come in and create some unique stuff. It's really just a matter if one is passionate and/or savy enough to take on such a task.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike N and jtkuga

Warlee

Starting to Get Obsessed
Apr 13, 2022
101
833
Michigan
Ok, here is the link, you can skip the first 10/12 mins that is in Italian and get to the interview in English
(A full 100% English version will be out early next week)

I kindly ask the admin to remove the message if it is against the rules

Iā€™m only about halfway through the video, but wow. If STG controls 80% of the pipe tobacco market that is very bad.

It also makes me wonder if the speed at which they are doing this (shutting down, destroying machines, etc) is due to a worry that they may be running afoul of anti-trust laws. Get rid of the factories and machines as quick as possible so there is no recourse to be had.

It seems they did not want the factories or portfolios, just the market share.
 

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
13,008
22,104
SE PA USA
We know from a statement on another thread today by one of the worldā€™s most knowledgeable persons on the subject that, demographics, regulation and other obstacles notwithstanding, ā€œThe U.S. pipe tobacco market is still very profitableā€¦ā€

The US pipe tobacco market is still very profitable for STG.

Question: Have you stopped to think about why the US pipe tobacco market is still very profitable for STG?
Answer: Because they don't f^ck around with small batches and low volume legacy blends. And they squash the competition.

Other companies may find success with different business models, but STG deleted Mac Baren and it's blends to keep the company very profitable.
 

telescopes

Pipe Dreamer and Star Gazer
The US pipe tobacco market is still very profitable for STG.

Question: Have you stopped to think about why the US pipe tobacco market is still very profitable for STG?
Answer: Because they don't f^ck around with small batches and low volume legacy blends. And they squash the competition.

Other companies may find success with different business models, but STG deleted Mac Baren and it's blends to keep the company very profitable.
Given that some of those blends will still exist, subtract overhead and production costs saved by closing the factories, itā€™s quite likely they will get a positive return on the 70+ million they spent. Remember , many of thise blends will be sold in Europe and other places even if they arenā€™t sold in the USA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: woodsroad

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
13,008
22,104
SE PA USA
Given that some of those blends will still exist, subtract overhead and production costs saved by closing the factories, itā€™s quite likely they will get a positive return on the 70+ million they spent. Remember , many of thise blends will be sold in Europe and other places even if they arenā€™t sold in the USA.
I expect that STG will recover their investment rather quickly. Wouldnā€™t it be great to be able to see a graph of sales, gross and net both pre and post sale?
 

telescopes

Pipe Dreamer and Star Gazer
I expect that STG will recover their investment rather quickly. Wouldnā€™t it be great to be able to see a graph of sales, gross and net both pre and post sale?
I am wondering what tax write offs they were able to apply in Denmark. It might very well be that the investment ā€œlossā€ will help eliminate many possible tax liabilities the company faced previously. Leonard made the decisions but he did so using data. He comes across as intelligent. I am sure STG considered wisely before acting. We will see. To be continued ā€¦
 
  • Love
  • Haha
Reactions: Elric and woodsroad