igloo said:
The thread doesn't really bother me. I can understand why some people would be offended, but I thought it was entertaining and a good discussion. There are some moderate personal attacks, but nothing here screams to me that the thread should be closed, but let's please stop the personal attacks.
octavius said:
I think it is a valid point that you "wear" your pipe.
There are appropriate times to be wearing a ratty t-shirt and beat-up sneakers.
There are also appropriate times to be wearing a jacket and tie.
I think different pipes would potentially go with those two different outfits.
I have a few MM Corn Cobs. I hardly ever smoke them, but they do have their place. I appreciate that they offer an inexpensive alternative that might make it easier for a budget-conscious consumer to enter our hobby. For me, anything that helps support the growth of the pipe smoker market is a positive thing.
Let me know when the thread starts to pick on Pete fans. I want in on that one. I own 3 Petes myself.
You know what would be a fun thread?
We all list each brand of pipe we have. It might be interesting to see how narrow or how broad our collections are.
Not here. Start a new thread please.
And Lawrence emailed me for my opinion, so here it is ...Allright everyone has had there fun and we are getting near death threats . I think we should close the thread and pick on Pete fans next.
The thread doesn't really bother me. I can understand why some people would be offended, but I thought it was entertaining and a good discussion. There are some moderate personal attacks, but nothing here screams to me that the thread should be closed, but let's please stop the personal attacks.
octavius said:
This reminded me a an interesting thing that Mike Holba of Nat Sherman said when I interviewed him. I'm paraphrasing, but he said that a pipe is like an accessory, similar to a piece of jewelry, or a tie, or even footwear. He said he oftens asks the question, "what type of pipe are you wearing?"I do have an MM and I think it smokes great, especially around a campfire. Although, if I was to forever live on an island with only one pipe, my corncob would be left behind. On that same line of logic if I were to take a pipe to smoke at a wedding reception it would not be the corncob either.
I think it is a valid point that you "wear" your pipe.
There are appropriate times to be wearing a ratty t-shirt and beat-up sneakers.
There are also appropriate times to be wearing a jacket and tie.
I think different pipes would potentially go with those two different outfits.
I have a few MM Corn Cobs. I hardly ever smoke them, but they do have their place. I appreciate that they offer an inexpensive alternative that might make it easier for a budget-conscious consumer to enter our hobby. For me, anything that helps support the growth of the pipe smoker market is a positive thing.
Let me know when the thread starts to pick on Pete fans. I want in on that one. I own 3 Petes myself.
You know what would be a fun thread?
We all list each brand of pipe we have. It might be interesting to see how narrow or how broad our collections are.
Not here. Start a new thread please.