Oh, well, that's a great question. As I'm a very new piper (2.5 weeks, or thereabouts), I'm still trying to figure out what I like. I KNOW that I like English blends, VaPers, VaBurs, you name it. Very fond of Black Frigate. I've tried one aromatic (Lane 1Q), and have another ready to try (kindly reccomended by @ChasingEmbers): Belmont Station. I do enjoy comparing the various flavors of newly acquired blends, and so I buy some, try it, compare to others.
Currently, I have picked:
Black Frigate
HH Old Dark Fired
Escudo Deluxe Navy Rolls and/or Dunhill Navy Rolls
SPC Mississippi River
SPC Plum Pudding/Plum Pudding SR
Dunhill NightCap
G.L. Pease Gaslight and Quiet Nights
There are others, and I'm trying a lot of different blends, but that's it so far.
CW