***What Are You Smoking, November 2023?***

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tate

Lifer
Sep 27, 2023
1,272
17,733
30
Northern Illinois
Actually it tastes very good, but it doesn't have a lot of balls for my liking. If I compare it to a lot of other Balkans, it's not my favourite. Fusilier's Ration has a stronger topping, which I like. I'm not averse to any toppings per se (except maybe whatever's on Haddo's Delight...but it ages well.) Abingdon has more complexity and more flavour. So does Charring Cross, Black House, Magnum Opus, Red Rapparee...I could go on. When the Plum Pudding was fresh I found it kind of dry, and not huge on flavour. Now with a good deal of age on it, I find it more flavourful. FWIW. YMMV.
Thanks! I totally get that!
 

Winnipeger

Lifer
Sep 9, 2022
1,288
9,690
Winnipeg
Here's the Nuttens/Ropp I just bought. I couldn't not buy this. I LOVE this stummel shape. I had the same Ropp but I traded it in to SP, because I just could not abide the horn stem on it, and I've lamented that they don't sell this exact stummel with a vulcanite stem. This stummel, hand chosen by Nuttens, with a hand-cut vulcanite stem! It was a no brainer, impulse buy. I didn't know these Nuttens/Ropps existed. Hopefully they'll be able to save the factory!

1661_591_img-9692.jpg
1661_8257_img-9696.jpg
My old Ropp
IMG_2881.jpg
 

BenMN

Lifer
Jun 21, 2023
2,181
37,311
St. Paul, MN
Here's the Nuttens/Ropp I just bought. I couldn't not buy this. I LOVE this stummel shape. I had the same Ropp but I traded it in to SP, because I just could not abide the horn stem on it, and I've lamented that they don't sell this exact stummel with a vulcanite stem. This stummel, hand chosen by Nuttens, with a hand-cut vulcanite stem! It was a no brainer, impulse buy. I didn't know these Nuttens/Ropps existed. Hopefully they'll be able to save the factory!

View attachment 262920
View attachment 262921
My old Ropp
View attachment 262922
That's actually pretty incredible. Nice get.
 

MidTNPiper

Might Stick Around
Jul 6, 2023
82
1,075
Nashville, TN
I think my next pipe will be dedicated to Haunted Bookshop.
Yours looks perfect for it.

Hal in the kk. I think this makes about 30 smokes in it so far.

View attachment 262926
I actually have a dedicated HBS pipe, and this not it…wanted to try something different - glad I did. My HBS pipe is a rossi 8114. It’s been rode hard and needed some time off.
 

Tate

Lifer
Sep 27, 2023
1,272
17,733
30
Northern Illinois
Here's the Nuttens/Ropp I just bought. I couldn't not buy this. I LOVE this stummel shape. I had the same Ropp but I traded it in to SP, because I just could not abide the horn stem on it, and I've lamented that they don't sell this exact stummel with a vulcanite stem. This stummel, hand chosen by Nuttens, with a hand-cut vulcanite stem! It was a no brainer, impulse buy. I didn't know these Nuttens/Ropps existed. Hopefully they'll be able to save the factory!

View attachment 262920
View attachment 262921
My old Ropp
View attachment 262922
Gorgeous pipe and awesome acquisition!
 

Lyon0oq

Part of the Furniture Now
Jul 31, 2012
569
5,342
55
New Providence, NJ
Great series. I followed that one up with Band of Brothers. I've lost count as to how many times I've seen Band of Brothers. If you haven't watched it yet, All is Quiet on the Western Front is phenomenal.
I actually started with Band of Brothers about a month ago and then watched The Pacific. Berger's remake of AQotWF is, as you already commented, phenomenal.
 

hoipolloiglasgow

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 14, 2023
566
3,980
United States
Actually it tastes very good, but it doesn't have a lot of balls for my liking. If I compare it to a lot of other Balkans, it's not my favourite. Fusilier's Ration has a stronger topping, which I like. I'm not averse to any toppings per se (except maybe whatever's on Haddo's Delight...but it ages well.) Abingdon has more complexity and more flavour. So does Charring Cross, Black House, Magnum Opus, Red Rapparee...I could go on. When the Plum Pudding was fresh I found it kind of dry, and not huge on flavour. Now with a good deal of age on it, I find it more flavourful. FWIW. YMMV.
I'm gonna have to age mine. I mean it rarely has gotten touched much anyway so I'll just see how it does later on. This is the Special Reserve Flake version. I found it to be really rich and the latakia is heavy, but not the same quality as the latakia in GL Pease. It has some rough edges too. I hope it will mellow some with time so it's not a waste. There are many blends I enjoy more and don't understand what the fuss is about.
 

haebar

Can't Leave
Nov 10, 2014
348
6,245
East Tennessee
Starting my morning with some Haunted Bookshop in a Dunhill Shell.

Dunhill-Tanshell-billiard.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.