Tonight it's Captain Black original in my longtime favorite workhorse pipe, a bent Country Gentleman cob outfitted with a bent C type Forever Stem.
View attachment 294024
For comparison sake I'm now smoking Lane RLP-6 in the same pipe, since I had heard it was the same blend as Captain Black original, and while it's certainly very similar to Captain Black original it's not exactly the same. The topping seems to be the same on both blends, but Captain Black is noticably more heavily topped and features more black canvendish and less burley; giving the smoke from Captain Black greater density and more sweetness than RLP-6.
I'm surprised to say it but I actually prefer Captain Black over RLP-6. I very much like the flavor of the topping and it's more prominent in Captain Black, whereas with RLP-6 you get less of that delicious sweet cream topping flavor and more of what I can only describe as a "cheap burley" taste. I also find the retrohale on Captain Black original to be completely smooth and comfortable, whereas the retrohale on Lane RLP-6 tends to sting my sinuses a bit.
So, between the two I'll stick with Captain Black. For a visual comparison, here's Captain Black original on the left vs Lane RLP-6 on the right:
Last edited: