So far, I've liked all the Wilke aromatics (and non-aromatics, too!) that I've tried. While none of the ones I've sampled thus far have been soaked/saturated in the manner of some of the Sutliff or Lane aros, the Wilke aros might not be satisfactory to a pipe smoker who appreciates an "honest" or more direct tobacco taste....for that, I'd direct them to the English/Balkan mixtures that Wilke also sells (and which are very good). The aromatic dressings John Brandt uses are applied with a pretty light hand, and all seem of good quality. @jiminks has probably tried most of their lineup, and could recommend which he enjoys most. @Backwoods Briar has been trying them, too.How do you like it? I almost bought some of that earlier today.
Thus far, I have tried the Cherry Cavendish (a non-biting cherry), Rumcake, No. 515, Gramercy Park, Chocolate, and Vermont Maple Cavendish. Of those, I've enjoyed the Cherry, Vermont Maple, and Rumcake the most (I have also preferred the Wilke Vermont Maple over C&D's Autumn Maple). The 515 is a rum aromatic, with a less obvious dressing than the Rumcake version, and the VA component seems somewhat more prominent in that iteration.