***What Are You Smoking, August 2020?***

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

36 Fresh Chacom Pipes
3 Fresh Bill Shalosky Pipes
180 Fresh Peterson Pipes
34 Fresh Rossi Pipes
120 Fresh Savinelli Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

marlinspike

Can't Leave
Feb 19, 2020
488
3,619
The PNW
How do you like it? I almost bought some of that earlier today.
So far, I've liked all the Wilke aromatics (and non-aromatics, too!) that I've tried. While none of the ones I've sampled thus far have been soaked/saturated in the manner of some of the Sutliff or Lane aros, the Wilke aros might not be satisfactory to a pipe smoker who appreciates an "honest" or more direct tobacco taste....for that, I'd direct them to the English/Balkan mixtures that Wilke also sells (and which are very good). The aromatic dressings John Brandt uses are applied with a pretty light hand, and all seem of good quality. @jiminks has probably tried most of their lineup, and could recommend which he enjoys most. @Backwoods Briar has been trying them, too.

Thus far, I have tried the Cherry Cavendish (a non-biting cherry), Rumcake, No. 515, Gramercy Park, Chocolate, and Vermont Maple Cavendish. Of those, I've enjoyed the Cherry, Vermont Maple, and Rumcake the most (I have also preferred the Wilke Vermont Maple over C&D's Autumn Maple). The 515 is a rum aromatic, with a less obvious dressing than the Rumcake version, and the VA component seems somewhat more prominent in that iteration.
 
May 2, 2020
4,664
23,786
Louisiana
So far, I've liked all the Wilke aromatics (and non-aromatics, too!) that I've tried. While none of the ones I've sampled thus far have been soaked/saturated in the manner of some of the Sutliff or Lane aros, the Wilke aros might not be satisfactory to a pipe smoker who appreciates an "honest" or more direct tobacco taste....for that, I'd direct them to the English/Balkan mixtures that Wilke also sells (and which are very good). The aromatic dressings John Brandt uses are applied with a pretty light hand, and all seem of good quality. @jiminks has probably tried most of their lineup, and could recommend which he enjoys most. @Backwoods Briar has been trying them, too.

Thus far, I have tried the Cherry Cavendish (a non-biting cherry), Rumcake, No. 515, Gramercy Park, Chocolate, and Vermont Maple Cavendish. Of those, I've enjoyed the Cherry, Vermont Maple, and Rumcake the most (I have also preferred the Wilke Vermont Maple over C&D's Autumn Maple). The 515 is a rum aromatic, with a less obvious dressing than the Rumcake version, and the VA component seems somewhat more prominent in that iteration.
I just bought a few blends today, including the two new ones Jim reviewed. Looking forward to trying them.
 
Apr 26, 2020
2,239
47,249
Northern California
So far, I've liked all the Wilke aromatics (and non-aromatics, too!) that I've tried. While none of the ones I've sampled thus far have been soaked/saturated in the manner of some of the Sutliff or Lane aros, the Wilke aros might not be satisfactory to a pipe smoker who appreciates an "honest" or more direct tobacco taste....for that, I'd direct them to the English/Balkan mixtures that Wilke also sells (and which are very good). The aromatic dressings John Brandt uses are applied with a pretty light hand, and all seem of good quality. @jiminks has probably tried most of their lineup, and could recommend which he enjoys most. @Backwoods Briar has been trying them, too.

Thus far, I have tried the Cherry Cavendish (a non-biting cherry), Rumcake, No. 515, Gramercy Park, Chocolate, and Vermont Maple Cavendish. Of those, I've enjoyed the Cherry, Vermont Maple, and Rumcake the most (I have also preferred the Wilke Vermont Maple over C&D's Autumn Maple). The 515 is a rum aromatic, with a less obvious dressing than the Rumcake version, and the VA component seems somewhat more prominent in that iteration.
 

weezell

Lifer
Oct 12, 2011
13,653
49,171
Warrior Plug in a Meer ...
fewyQVe.jpg
 

ophiuchus

Lifer
Mar 25, 2016
1,650
2,501
I usually don’t smoke on the work stretch, but tonight I cheated. I got home to an evening I could describe as chilly, homemade chicken soup weather. Though I love summer, this has been the first evening to suggest an autumnal encroachment, and I had to take a walk ... and revisit Latakia, which has been in hiding from my indulgences since spring (with the possible exception of some Gaslight). So I took along this ...

E0670D23-2A64-4BC4-BE06-DD9E9D26C811.jpeg

Dunhill My Mixture 965, from a tin purchased in 2014 and jarred the beginning of last winter, in a Stanwell Black Diamond 86. What a terrific way to welcome back the Lat!
 

JimInks

Sultan of Smoke
Aug 31, 2012
64,886
656,336
Not far from finishing this bowl of C&D Burley Ribbon Cut in a 1970s slight bend black sandblasted Comoy's Silver Cloud 624 sitter with a silver pearl gray acrylic saddle stem.

Now smoking year 1969 Lane Crown Achievement in a black pebble finish straight 2003 Cavicchi C. Fatto A Mano lovat with a black acrylic saddle stem. Have enough for one more bowl.
 
Apr 26, 2020
2,239
47,249
Northern California
The Rum and Maple sounds like a really nice autumn mix, and I'll probably add a couple of ounces to my next Wilke order.
So far I have enjoyed all of the Wilke tobaccos. To me the blends combine a great tobacco taste with a subtle flavoring. When I want a straight strong tobacco like Peterson flake that’s what I go to. When I want flavor and a mellow smoke the Wilke’s deliver. After dinner or an afternoon with beer I really enjoy a Wilke 191 or a chocolate and or a Vermont maple. I find that the Wilke and the Edward G Robinson blend deliver flavor and tobacco goodness!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.