I had a Stanwell bulldog back in the 70s. Smoked a little t of Rattrays in it. A decent pipe
Well, that's partly correct. But this does not apply to every stummel. Let's say Dunhill 4103, the classical Billard and most sold Dunhill Shape. Yes, there is a high chance that they buy the stummels very roughly pre drilled from second sources. By the way, many other very popular big pipe- brands doing it just like that. But let's say a Dunhill 5128 or a Bing is made- here it is very likely that the stummel is made in London too. Either way, for me the pipe is made at Dunhill, a small and insignificant feature doesn't make this or that pipe more or less Dunhill.
Can you guys tell me where I can learn more about things like this in the pipe industry? It would be fun to know more about the whole process from burl in the ground to pipe in the hand. I've seen Father the Flame but it was more general and less in depth.Maybe this surprises you. Two decades ago, when the pipes were called Dunhill and there was a Dunhill heading the company, the company "Hijos de Emilio Navarro", from Valencia, Spain, was already turning bowls for Dunhill. This company is the owner of the Bruken, ENA and Emilio Navarro pipe brands, it has been manufacturing pipes for more than a century and if you don't take a look at it, you are missing something interesting.
It would be interesting if you provide data from your statements.You are amusing, but entirely wrong.
I would be more than happy to be proven wrong, but you haven’t offered anything other than your opinion, which you are, of course, entitled to.
When you have been in the hobby for a long time, you meet people who have been in the hobby for a long time and you know sources of information. you get to know some manufacturer or otherCan you guys tell me where I can learn more about things like this in the pipe industry? It would be fun to know more about the whole process from burl in the ground to pipe in the hand. I've seen Father the Flame but it was more general and less in depth.
Pipe sellers continue to desperately try to prop up the old "Dunhill" name and it's associated profit margins, even though the pipes are made in various locals outside the UK.It would be interesting if you provide data from your statements.
I do not deny that you may be right, but for it to pass from the category of opinion, there should be data.
Starting with:
A)"that “Dunhill” no longer makes pipes.
It may be true, but today you can buy them at: ...
The "Dunhill" name is now just a brand, not a company. The Dunhill luxe goods division is owned by Richemont Holdings (UK) Limited. The TM for tobacco use is owned by BAT.B)The Dunhill company no longer exists.
This is directly wrong, the company exists. You may have the opinion that Dunhill is a brand of smoking articles that mutated into a luxury brand, but it is exactly the opposite, Dunhill was from its creation a brand of articles for wealthy people that for a period of time manufactured and sold articles for smokers.
You are correct. My bad.C) the Dunhill name was removed from the pipes.
What the pipes have stamped today is exactly "alfred The White Spot Dunhills". In my opinion that is not removing his name from the pipes. In fact the Word Dunhill is on the pipe.
"Pipe Factory" is a broad term to use for a place that doesn't actually make the stummels.D) the pipes are no longer made in the Dunhill factory, or anywhere in the UK,
This is the point where you are perhaps closest to reason, it is likely that at least some process is carried out in other pipe factories in Europe. Even so, there is a Dunhill pipe factory in London, it is at 32 St Andrews Rd, London E17 6BQ, United Kingdom
Agreed.E) their ridiculous price.
That the price is ridiculous is a personal appreciation. I probably agree with you, but it's still a matter of point of view.
As far as I know, Mimmo doesn't harvest Heather, he buys Briar from harvesters on the coast of Spain, France and Italy. I also don't think he has the capacity to make much more than a couple dozen pipes a year. The Briar is deceptive, selecting the best of all briars does not guarantee that the bowl will not be ruined during manufacturing. What Dunhill does is buy turned bowls that have come out of excellent quality at the end of the process.I can’t remember for which big pipe company it is, in the video someone put up in another thread about briar, that Mimmo, the Italian briar expert and pipe-maker, is shown, choosing briar roots and digging them up, transporting them, storing them, cutting the wood, and, making a mass of stummels. He’s a big name in that world, amongs the top of the top pipe-makers and I guess I could see, maybe, how Dunhill could pay him extra to take more time to choose higher quality briar and make the highest quality stummels? If there is such a thing?
Great to hear, congrats! I prefer them, myself. The new ones are nice, but (to me) they are Stanwell in markings only. But, I bet they smoke well too. Just without that connection to the masters. IMOLast week, I saw a estate Stanwell (pre-2020 Danske made) Legend on SP. The price seemed reasonable to me. I went ahead and clicked 'buy" and added some Bob's Chocolate Flake to bring the total up and over the free shipping thresh hold. It arrived in 3 days. It is a handsome and clean pipe and has a nice open draw. I couldnt be happier. You guys were right about the Danish made Stanwells.
Check out listings in The Danish Pipe Shop's estate section.Most of my collection are Stanwells, pre 1990. In our pipe shop in Canada they were always the best price and great smokers. I think I have too many of them. I’d like to get into some other lines. I’ve got a couple of late models but many were heavily varnished.
Good Stan’s are available, mostly on the bay now.
Father the Flame showed him going out with some guys to harvest some burls. But maybe this was just him going with the harvesters in Italy for the movie.As far as I know, Mimmo doesn't harvest Heather, he buys Briar from harvesters on the coast of Spain, France and Italy. I also don't think he has the capacity to make much more than a couple dozen pipes a year. The Briar is deceptive, selecting the best of all briars does not guarantee that the bowl will not be ruined during manufacturing. What Dunhill does is buy turned bowls that have come out of excellent quality at the end of the process.