I have to admit, you've got me curious about Lee pipes—if I were to look for one to add to my collection, should I be looking for a five point star or a seven point star? Should I avoid ones with two stars and look for only three and five stars? Is the quality appreciably different when it comes to the five star period and the seven, and number of stars? Do they all have stingers?
There are no bad Lee pipes.
But the first two series, the early 7 and middle 5 point inlaid star runs are obviously higher quality than the last run of stamped star Lees.
The first reason why, is they had real jeweler’s gold stars inlaid (not stamped) into the stems. That’s purdy!
But also, the quality of craftsmanship is a bit (not a whole lot just a little) higher in early pipes than the last ones.
As for briar quality I think they all run about the same, which is another strange thing about Lee pipes.
Ever see a really dynamite flame grain or birdseye or straight grain pipe that’s just flat frigging fantastic?
Sure you have. I own some of those pipes, but except for one they aren’t made by Lee.
That one Lee, an extremely early 1946 Lee stamped “A Lee Star Grade Pipe” instead of Pipes by Lee, and it’s only a Two Star, has bragging quality flame grain. All the rest have excellent, tight, mixed and cross grained briar, very well selected, but not flashy or showy.
Why do I think the 5 pointed stars are the tops?
Lee raised the price of his pipes to five dollars a star when the switch was made, sometime in the early 1950s.
Before, a Two Star was $5 and a Three Star $10.
Lee had a good customer base already.
When they shelled out $15 instead of $10 for the most common Three Star grade, they expected (and received) just a little better pipe. Not much, but I think it’s detectable.