I'm guessing they're going to release the same things every year or two but have variety in the shapes they offer. Just a guess though.If it's listed as 'Heritage' then it's not uncommon for it to have some smalls dings, fills or even pits. At least in my experience, I bought an XL11/Sherlock Holmes Original for the 2022 Christmas release and was a little disappointed with a few pits. Since then it's garnered even more dings and dents and maybe it's the copper but it all feels like it fits the pipe. Doesn't hurt that it's a $130 spigot rather than a $180+ one either.
I ended up caving last night and went with a 102 Heritage. I'm fairly confident I could find an X105 rusticated somewhere at least in the next couple weeks so if the 102 is disappointingly small then I'll send it back to SPC and go for the 105.
Still wish they hadn't been so miserly with the straight billiards this year. Used to be they'd have 103, 104, X105, 106 and even my beloved and oft forgotten 107. What's with that?