The 4AB ticked all my Peterson boxes and I've been very happy with those. There was a limited release of a Sherlock Watson "Junior" earlier this year and those went quickly, but I was happy to get one - I like the chunky rustication and I'm a fan of their "short" pipes and that's kind of the Sherlock equivalent of a "short" - kind of like Walther PPK sized pipes. I picked up an Iora spigot XL02 sandblasted in a natural finish (I think that was a special release, can't remember) and that is one of my favorite pipes.
This particular shape wasn't for me, but glad those that wanted it were able to get one. This may be anathema to some, but I read a lot of Mark Twain growing up and just never had the connection to his work I had to many other authors, Doyle and Poe among them, but maybe that's just a reflection on my other tastes and interests at certain stages, lol. Now I'm more "mature", haha, maybe I should revisit.
@craig61a - with all your Peterson experience I can understand your frustration with less than satisfactory standards. I haven't had that issue in any obvious way (can always return to SP) but I don't have the years of experience to compare to the older models. I have purchased a couple of shapes that once received didn't really do much for me, but that's just sorting out preferences. I do have an old 999 I was happy to purchase from
@ssjones that is a fine pipe, and also a favorite.