Opening A Tin? Show Us!

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

mtwaller

Lifer
Nov 21, 2018
1,566
8,819
36
Atlanta, GA
Let us know what you think @mtwaller
If it's been undisturbed in that jar then the topping shouldn't have diminished much, or at all. Quite possible it's even had the opposite effect.
It’s very good. I was worried that 6 years in a jar would have made it really smooth and soft, but it has a nice zing to it that I quite enjoy!
 

Goblin_Walrus

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 1, 2025
745
10,630
Texas
The residue on the ribbons gave me pause at first, but a nice flashlight gave me some sparkly insight as to the contents of this tin of Dunhill Nightcap from 2008. Just enjoyed a bowl with my brother and a friend out of a workhorse Pete alongside some current-production Peterson Nightcap. IMG_8083.jpegIMG_8084.jpeg
 
Jun 9, 2018
5,004
16,228
England
May 2, 2018
4,121
31,888
Bucks County, PA
Brown Flake is amazing stuff. I love its deep, earthy flavour. I've got some in the cellar that i'm aging so I only smoke the fresh stuff, at the moment. Even fresh out the tin it tastes as if its been aged for 10 years🤤
Agreed! Brown Flake is probably my favorite of JF Germain’s offerings. It’s a shame that it’s hard to acquire anymore. Definitely a treat in the bowl. 🤙☕
 

NoogaPipe

Lurker
Jan 11, 2022
16
174
Yeah, that’s the good stuff there.
Is that some rust on the tin I see? It’s hard to make out from the picture.
It is! I've opened several of these 2017 tins and there's always been a bit of rusting around the seal. It has never compromised the tobacco itself. At least, thus far. These Gawith tins are the only ones that have ever done this to me.
 

Goblin_Walrus

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 1, 2025
745
10,630
Texas
It is! I've opened several of these 2017 tins and there's always been a bit of rusting around the seal. It has never compromised the tobacco itself. At least, thus far. These Gawith tins are the only ones that have ever done this to me.
I had a very rusty tin of 2018 HH Bold Kentucky that smelled and tasted terribly of metal, but after a day or two in a new jar with the lid open it lost the metal taste, and two days with the jar closed later it was one of the best smokes of my life. I reckon that jar is still floating around here, I gotta find that sucker. But yeah rust isn’t bad all the time, and even when it is you still have a chance.
 

BriaronBoerum

Can't Leave
Jan 13, 2025
409
1,913
Brooklyn, NY
I had a very rusty tin of 2018 HH Bold Kentucky that smelled and tasted terribly of metal, but after a day or two in a new jar with the lid open it lost the metal taste, and two days with the jar closed later it was one of the best smokes of my life. I reckon that jar is still floating around here, I gotta find that sucker. But yeah rust isn’t bad all the time, and even when it is you still have a chance.
Get your daily iron supplement!