That is a great story! I used to travel to NYC for work with some frequency from 2000 to 2018. I think I visited the location on Lexington (it had a completely oak storefront, very narrow), in the early 2000's, pretty posh digs! Sadly NY taxes and NYC rates made purchasing pipe tobacco foolish. I had to drive past three PA shops on my way home, at their prices, it was a two-for one vs NYC. But, it was fun to window shop and usually I'd indulge myself with a modestly priced cigar. I did get tossed from the park at the NYC Library on the last trip, don't try smoking in there.....
I miss seeing the guys at the NYC club, it's been two years since I've been in the city.