I've found that various butt sweat varietals have different characteristics, like "hot dog water", "Formaggio", and "clam dip".
Name Your Nilla
- Thread starter Old_Newby
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
I heard that with the perfect humidity you can get a note of tuna can juice.
Sutliff D-40 Vanilla tastes like Bryer's French Vanilla ice cream to me and is probably the best.
MacBaren Vanilla Flake is excellent as karam recommends.
I just bought some Boswell's P&T Vanilla Cream and I'll let you know how it goes.
MacBaren Vanilla Flake is excellent as karam recommends.
I just bought some Boswell's P&T Vanilla Cream and I'll let you know how it goes.
Planta Danish Black Vanilla is the only vanilla aromatic I've had that tastes like it smells. First rate stuff.
Sutliff's D40 Vanilla has a unique aroma and taste, spicy and sweet. Great on its own, or with maybe just a pinch of shag cut like Five Brothers or Penny Farthing to brass it up.
Sutliff's D40 Vanilla has a unique aroma and taste, spicy and sweet. Great on its own, or with maybe just a pinch of shag cut like Five Brothers or Penny Farthing to brass it up.
MB Vanilla Roll Cake. The tin note is fantastic and the taste is mainly tobacco, but I can still taste the vanilla bean. Probably too strong for my money. Time will tell if it will calm down enough to be complimentary. I can't see myself ever buying more than the 1lb I already have. Actually, I can't see myself buying anymore vanilla tobacco, besides maybe a tin of Dan Tobacco Honeydew Vanilla if I need to round up to free shipping...
For what it's worth, Bob's Chocolate probably has my preferred amount of vanilla in a blend.
For what it's worth, Bob's Chocolate probably has my preferred amount of vanilla in a blend.
Thanks.. I was gifted a sample of Mac Baren Vanilla Flake that I will try soon. I do want to try roll cake but that appears a high cost item right now. The Bobs Honeydew has came up a lot and I have seen it on several Top 5 lists on YouTube.
Mac Baren Vanilla Flake for me. Hands down. Vanilla is subtle but prevalent, and superb VA flavor is forward.
Sutliff Z92 Vanilla Custard.
In my opinion one of the fullest flavored aromatics out there, definitely worth a try: Sutliff Z92 Vanilla Custard | Buy Sutliff Pipe Tobacco at Smokingpipes.com - https://www.smokingpipes.com/pipe-tobacco/Sutliff/Z92-Vanilla-Custard/product_id/151168/bulk/
In my opinion one of the fullest flavored aromatics out there, definitely worth a try: Sutliff Z92 Vanilla Custard | Buy Sutliff Pipe Tobacco at Smokingpipes.com - https://www.smokingpipes.com/pipe-tobacco/Sutliff/Z92-Vanilla-Custard/product_id/151168/bulk/
I hear Bengal Slices tastes like vanilla, you should try that one.
Vanilla Roll Cake gets another vote.
1-Q is not vanilla…I’m not even sure it has a distinguishable flavor. Nasty?
Vanilla Roll Cake gets another vote.
1-Q is not vanilla…I’m not even sure it has a distinguishable flavor. Nasty?
I enjoy Arrowhead quite a bit, more than just vanilla, and more than just burley and cavandish
I too like the Mac Baren offerings.
Vanilla Cream Flake is the stronger of the two, both the underlying tobacco and the intensity of the vanilla topping. The vanilla flavorings in each are considerably different. VCF is spicier and applied a little heavier, as I mentioned. In Vanilla Roll Cake, the vanilla is softer and I think a little sweeter, but applied a little more lightly.
In both VCF and VRC, the underlying tobaccos are not hidden at all, and are very good. I think VCF without the topping would be a fantastic VaBur.
Vanilla Cream Flake is the stronger of the two, both the underlying tobacco and the intensity of the vanilla topping. The vanilla flavorings in each are considerably different. VCF is spicier and applied a little heavier, as I mentioned. In Vanilla Roll Cake, the vanilla is softer and I think a little sweeter, but applied a little more lightly.
In both VCF and VRC, the underlying tobaccos are not hidden at all, and are very good. I think VCF without the topping would be a fantastic VaBur.
One of my favorites is CAO Bella Vanilla--very affordable, very consistent, very definitely sweet vanilla, and not on the goopy side of things--though it will linger in your pipe.
I've tried almost all vanilla's since I started on the pipe 18 months ago or so and I always come back to Sutliff Panna Cotta. It burns cool and taste as good as it smells, even straight out of the tin (I had no idea you were supposed to dry tobacco out until reading forums here).