If You Were Stranded On a Deserted Island With Only One Tobacco...

[hawky454]

Sherm Natman? He had a lot to say while he was here, I’m pretty sure he got the boot. I could be wrong that was just my impression.

 

[trouttimes]

No question...965

 

[brian64]

Sherm Natman?
Would he comment on those who gave multiple answers to a question which specifies one tobacco?? I thought of that, but decided that to point that out was boorish, so I didn't......

Sherm Natman? He had a lot to say while he was here, I’m pretty sure he got the boot. I could be wrong that was just my impression.

I was just joking of course...based on the desert island thread that Sherm started a while back. He was "enforcing the rules" with good humor (people are always trying to sneak extra stuff onto the island).
As for Sherm himself, I have no idea what happened to him...but I do seem to recall some sort of minor dust-up involving him a while back (don't remember what it was about). Most of us have had one or two of those from time to time...if everyone left or got banned on those occasions there would be few of us left.

 

[daytonsean]

Peterson Old Dublin.

 

[hoosierpipeguy]

SG Full Virginia Flake

 

[derhammer]

Nightcap :lol:

 

[haparnold]

Realistically, there are plenty of blends out there which are good enough that I'd keep smoking even if I only had the one.
One of my criteria for cellaring a blend is if it's good enough to me that I could handle it being my only tobacco. Among those blends is HH Burley Flake, so I guess I'll pick that one today.

 

[hauntedmyst]

Esoterica Penzance

 

[cigrmaster]

Since it has been five days since my last response, let me regale you with another favorite.
How about 2012 Wessex Brigade Campaign Dark Flake, mighty tasty.

 

[jrbjr]

Have been a fan of Dunhill Navy ROlls, so smooth

 

[ebnash]

Dunhill Flake
...and I’mready to get taken to the desert island because I only have about 1.5oz left...

 

[smudgersmissingleg]

Sam Gawith Full Virginia Plug.
Chris

 

[pipebuddy]

Peterson University Flake.

 

[oldmooner]

Sir Walter Raleigh. Been smoking it for 45 years. I know it is "common" and of the "drugstore" class, but I like it. I also like "screw-top" wines.

 

[Bengel]

The only one I think I've not soured on once- GLP Cairo

 

[SpookedPiper]

Sam Gawith cabbies mixture

 

[J.Henry845]

3P's if I also had a sharp knife to slice it. Without a knife it would be a cruel joke, like the ending of the Twilight Zone episode " Time Enough at Last."

 

[Chasing Embers]

3P's if I also had a sharp knife to slice it.

 

[oldtoby]

I'm thinkin' this week it'd be Rattray's Wallace Flake.

Harris, if you haven't tried this, you really should. Truly something I could smoke for mucho long time.

 

[autumnfog]

Capstan Blue.