If You Smoke Aromatics Is It The Tobacco You're Enjoying ?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,211
60,627
It's true. Mixture No. 79 used to be the standard joke blend on Forums, until chasing embers gave it a testimonial. So i tried it, and it met my tobacco forward criteria, and there is nothing wrong with the base tobacco either.
 

Brendan

Lifer
May 16, 2021
1,488
7,860
Cowra, New South Wales, Australia.
Yes, like my briskets, I prefer my baked potatoes smothered in goopy strawberry syrup and crushed Jolly Ranchers. puffy
Pfft...
I’d top that off with some shaved coconut and dark chocolate, put hairs on ya chest..puffy

Also, interesting comment on the LTF as I’m going to have my first bowl today and was blown away by the ‘pouch’ note - can’t wait to see how it tastes.

Really surprised at how aromatic is, was expecting it to be more like LNF with a subtle top note maybe - stuff smells like a chocolate we have down under called a cherry ripe.

Smelt so good I actually chewed on a small piece, shortly spat it out though and had some actual cherry ripe. :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: chopper
Pfft...
I’d top that off with some shaved coconut and dark chocolate, put hairs on ya chest..puffy

Also, interesting comment on the LTF as I’m going to have my first bowl today and was blown away by the ‘pouch’ note - can’t wait to see how it tastes.

Really surprised at how aromatic is, was expecting it to be more like LNF with a subtle top note maybe - stuff smells like a chocolate we have down under called a cherry ripe.

Smelt so good I actually chewed on a small piece, shortly spat it out though and had some actual cherry ripe. :rolleyes:
I think you’ll be surprised. I smoke LTF a lot, and the first quarter of the bowl, I can taste the coconut cavendish, but then it gives way to more of a Virginia experience through the rest. I like it a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brendan

Brendan

Lifer
May 16, 2021
1,488
7,860
Cowra, New South Wales, Australia.
Speaking back to aromatics, I’d smoke a lot more if they were medium to high in nicotine - I have limited experience mind you, but the reason I shied away from them was they were too mild for my liking.
Some one please correct me or offer alternatives if you find that wrong, or a generalisation of aromatic blends.
As I say, I have little experience with the vast amount of blends out there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chopper

pappymac

Lifer
Feb 26, 2015
3,553
5,031
Slidell, LA
It's true. Mixture No. 79 used to be the standard joke blend on Forums, until chasing embers gave it a testimonial. So i tried it, and it met my tobacco forward criteria, and there is nothing wrong with the base tobacco either.
You just caved to chasing embers pressure.
 

Perique

Lifer
Sep 20, 2011
4,098
3,886
www.tobaccoreviews.com
Really depends on what one means by “aromatic”. It’s a broad field. Are we talking Captain Black or are we talking Wilke 191? Etc.
Most mass market aromatics, frankly, suck. Many American boutique blending house’s aromatics (Wilke, Perett, Uhle) are fantastic. Many Scandi aromatics occupy the broad spectrum between burn-like-fire-with-some-sweet-fruit through simply sublime. Bottom line is this: aromatics encompass the broadest spectrum from absolute shit to divine. And they take the most work and practice to smoke properly. That they are so often recommended to beginners probably accounts the most towards why ours is a dwindling subculture of tobacco appreciation.

IOW: we recommend aromatics to beginners at our own peril. It’s self-defeating.
 
Really depends on what one means by “aromatic”. It’s a broad field. Are we talking Captain Black or are we talking Wilke 191? Etc.
Most mass market aromatics, frankly, suck. Many American boutique blending house’s aromatics (Wilke, Perett, Uhle) are fantastic. Many Scandi aromatics occupy the broad spectrum between burn-like-fire-with-some-sweet-fruit through simply sublime. Bottom line is this: aromatics encompass the broadest spectrum from absolute shit to divine. And they take the most work and practice to smoke properly. That they are so often recommended to beginners probably accounts the most towards why ours is a dwindling subculture of tobacco appreciation.

IOW: we recommend aromatics to beginners at our own peril. It’s self-defeating.
Damn Perique, long time. Are you just getting back on here? Great to see you. We need more of us geezers represented on the forums. Ha ha!!

and I agree on all but that non-aro smokers are dwindling. I don’t think since tobacco has become exclusively a corporate product a century or so ago has non-aros been more popular than aros.
 

bullet08

Lifer
Nov 26, 2018
10,241
41,526
RTP, NC. USA
It's really simple. If I smoke something, and it feels like sucking on a pop, I don't want it. I don't like cigarettes anymore, but I still want that "tobacco." Pipe smoke has to feel and taste like tobacco. I don't hate or dislike aromatics, just don't want them. I can get a bag of dum dums for less than 2 oz of pipe tobacco.
 

olkofri

Lifer
Sep 9, 2017
8,168
14,985
The Arm of Orion
It's really simple. If I smoke something, and it feels like sucking on a pop, I don't want it. I don't like cigarettes anymore, but I still want that "tobacco." Pipe smoke has to feel and taste like tobacco. I don't hate or dislike aromatics, just don't want them. I can get a bag of dum dums for less than 2 oz of pipe tobacco.
You really must try Warhorse Green!
?
 

mingc

Lifer
Jun 20, 2019
4,246
12,577
The Big Rock Candy Mountains
In the tobacco industry, tobaccos that have had a topping sprayed on after processing are technically “aromatics”.
If a flavor is added early in the processing, it is a casing. Technically if it is a flavored twist, or plug, or if the tobacco is merely flavored in the cavendish provess it os a non-aromatic. Usually casings and such merely enhancements to tobacco flavors, provide consistency crop to crop, or it provides a branded flavor but doesn’t cover up the tobacco flavors.

Toppings, as sprayed on aromatics are to provide an additional flavor other than to enhance tobaccos flavors.

It is tricky, because some aromatics may be very lightly applied, and indistinguishable from the tobaccos, and some non topped tobaccos like PS LTF have a strong smell before smoking them of coconut, but because it was applied in the cavendish process it is not a topping, nor an aromatic.
Ah thanks. I knew all that. What I don't know is what blends folks specifically mean when they say non-aromatics. For all we know, one man's "non-aromatic" is another's Exotic Passion and around here that would not surprise me at all, given the number of eccentric miscreats we have here.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Servant King

olkofri

Lifer
Sep 9, 2017
8,168
14,985
The Arm of Orion
Ah thanks. I knew all that. What I don't know is what blends folks specifically mean when they say non-aromatics. For all we know, one man's "non-aromatic" is another's Exotic Passion and around here that would not surprise me at all, given the number of eccentric miscreats we have here.
Remember, at one point latakia blends were called aromatics. Well, alright, 'fragant', which is the same thing.
 

Merton

Lifer
Jul 8, 2020
1,040
2,794
Boston, Massachusetts
Amphora full Aroma is a very nice blend. Don't be put off in trying it. Finally, find something you like and let those who think that they are superior sod off. It is good to be always be open to a new blend and it is good to have a number of blends to rotate to keep the palate cleansed. However, this is not a contest and those who think that they are superior are, well, not....
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaulTheScandinavian

bullet08

Lifer
Nov 26, 2018
10,241
41,526
RTP, NC. USA
Is Vodka not brewed with all the same grains as Whiskey?
Even if you count the effects of grain fermentation, Whisky is just dirty Vodka.
Not exactly. Whisky is usually made with barley. Whiskey on the other hand could be made with other grains. Vodka, traditionally, is made with rye. But in modern time, potatoes can be used. Whisky goes through further steps then vodka to be produced.