My favorite Cigarillos are Toscano shorts and Montecristo, Partagas chicos in 5 er pack,in Europe all these are more or less affordably priced ,being cheaper than in the U.S
Unfortunately, due to the US' trade embargo on Cuban goods, the Partagas Chicos are harder to come by here, which makes them more expensive than I'd like for a cigarillo, but the Chicos are probably my favorite. I believe they are a fair representation of Partagas' general flavor profile.
It's not a true cigarillo (to my mind, cigarillos are machine-made, short-filler) so much as a petit panatela or petit corona, but I had a Tatuaje Tattoo Needle the other night that was excellent. In the same vein, I also enjoy the Cohiba Red Dot Pequenos with the Cameroon wrappers.
Toscanos are great too, though I don't have enough experience to have a favorite brand