Breaking in an Uncoated New Pipe

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

36 Fresh Erik Stokkebye 4th Generation Pipes
180 Fresh Peterson Pipes
2 Fresh Kurt Balleby Pipes
24 Fresh Johs Pipes
12 Fresh Winslow Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
Back to cleaning the 2 bent stem pipes from EBay. Mire black gunk on the brush type cleaners with alcohol. Did about 8 cleaners this way and got the greatest part of the gunk out. I forgot to mention that when I pulled the stems off these pipes there was an aluminum filter system in each one. After using pliers I was able to remove them. Apparently they were designed to prevent condensation from reaching the public maker's mouth. It was also impossible to get a pipe cleaner through them into the bowl, so condenaation kept building up. It ruined the pipes and probably the smoker gave up on them. I revived them. All these filter contraptions that some pipemakers offered were not fixes at all, but exacerbated problems that plagued smokers. A good pipe cleaner is all that is required to keep a pipe doing what it was designed for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KORNEY

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
I have had such a bad time breaking in two pipes that I have begun using a honey coating, which at first seemed to work. But then the bottom half on a newer pipe stopped caking and now appears to be bare wood. What am I doing wrong?
 

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
OK, I must seem like a slow learner, but I am having trouble breaking in two pipes that remain bare wood in the bottom 1/3. I tried the honey and got blah results except for a terrific tongue bite. So, yes, I'll stop with the honey.
 

Roach1

Lifer
Nov 25, 2023
1,432
21,284
Germany
I tried honey also with blau results. I then washed out the honey and resanded. I have four pipes break in a after setting for about 15 years. I myself had better result with out anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnnyBeach
Aug 11, 2022
2,663
20,892
Cedar Rapids, IA
OK, I must seem like a slow learner, but I am having trouble breaking in two pipes that remain bare wood in the bottom 1/3. I tried the honey and got blah results except for a terrific tongue bite. So, yes, I'll stop with the honey.
Bare wood makes me think the chamber is getting too wet at the bottom. As John suggests, try smoking some partial bowls for a while. I find that it helps to tamp the ash inward and expose fresh tobacco at the edges and focus on relighting that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnnyBeach

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
Bare wood makes me think the chamber is getting too wet at the bottom. As John suggests, try smoking some partial bowls for a while. I find that it helps to tamp the ash inward and expose fresh tobacco at the edges and focus on relighting that.
I have noticed that when I tamp the ash, the tobacco starts to burn better. I use pipe cleaners frequently to remove excess condensation, so maybe I should try drying the tobacco more and maybe slow down smoking.
 

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
I am still wondering about using honey as an aid to building cake. I have an estate briar with a bent stem that has a fairly large bowl. I may try honey on the lower half with that one, trying to get the ash and bits of tobacco to cling to the bowl and start a cake. We'll see.
 

BayouGhost

Starting to Get Obsessed
Apr 10, 2024
126
1,176
Louisiana
I usually start with a VA blend or a VAPER and go very slow and just make sure I finish the bowl. Improvement occurs by the 3rd use and significantly after the 5th bowl and is almost fully blackened at that point. Make sure to clean off the ash between uses as it creates a temporary protective layer that prevents new carbon to adhere to the bowl. I will start with a VA even on pipes dedicated for burleys as I find it to create cake just a bit faster, but its not that important at the end of the day. For dedicated English blend pipes, I just go with a solid middle of the road blend.
 

The Novice Piper

Might Stick Around
May 14, 2024
58
120
United States
Over thinking is pipe smoking's worst enemy.
I've noticed on this forum there are questions galore on how to break in, how to pack, how to smoke, how to prevent tongue bite, how to this, that and another. In follow up to those questions are many lengthy, drawn-out and complex answers.
That said, in almost every single example, it is the simplest and most elementary approaches and answers that seem to be the best. This is a simple and relaxing hobby and if ever the phrase, "Less is more" is applicable.... pipe smoking is that case.

Of course, that is my opinion and it, along with two bucks, will get you a cup of coffee. Which, by the way, pairs wonderfully with a pipe. :col:

This hits the nail on the head. The whole point of pipe smoking is to be mindful of yourself and your surroundings in the present moment. Take a break from all the stressful nonsense of the day.

When you approach each bowl like a relaxing experiment, just playing around with the effects you get from doing various things, it all just kind of comes together. Every single bowl I smoke is an experiment that hopefully leads to a fantastic moment with me, myself, and I. Sometimes I get there and sometimes I don't. It doesn't matter what anyone else thinks.
 

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
I tried one more pipe with a honey coat on the bottom third and it seemed to work. But I am avoiding it, generally, because of tongue bite. One pipe that was stubbornly resisting break in seems to be building cake from the top of a 1/3 bowl down to the bottom. I can't say I'm thrilled with this but it appears to be working.
 

instymp

Lifer
Jul 30, 2012
2,451
1,133
I am still wondering about using honey as an aid to building cake. I have an estate briar with a bent stem that has a fairly large bowl. I may try honey on the lower half with that one, trying to get the ash and bits of tobacco to cling to the bowl and start a cake. We'll see.
Many moons ago, it was honey or grape jelly. Done them both 5+ decades ago, now I don't,
Load & smoke em.
 

jpmcwjr

Lifer
May 12, 2015
26,263
30,344
Carmel Valley, CA
I am still wondering about using honey as an aid to building cake. I have an estate briar with a bent stem that has a fairly large bowl. I may try honey on the lower half with that one, trying to get the ash and bits of tobacco to cling to the bowl and start a cake. We'll see.
If you want a soft crumbly cake, above is the way to go. I remove all ash before a the next bowl, and the cake I've build is solid, but not thick.
 

JohnnyBeach

Might Stick Around
May 21, 2024
99
55
Bangor, Maine
If you want a soft crumbly cake, above is the way to go. I remove all ash before a the next bowl, and the cake I've build is solid, but not thick.
So far, I have not built up a crumbly cake. I did have t=ouble keeping my pipe lit today with a aromatic blend, so I zapped 3 pipefuls in the microwave for 30 seconds. Made it a bit crispy but it stayed lit. Still not much action on the cake.
 

jpmcwjr

Lifer
May 12, 2015
26,263
30,344
Carmel Valley, CA
Why would you want to build cake? Cake just happens.

Would you Please put your location in your Profile!
.
How: Under your avatar, (top right, left most of three symbols) you choose "Account Details", which brings up "My Account". "My Location" is halfway down.