Well the next group I have tried and there are so many.
**C&D Autumn Evening-A Cavendish with a subtle maple/vanilla note. I found the maple note to strong for me and am not a fan. It's sweet and if you like maple, this is your blend.
**Pembroke 1999-I found this to be mild and the cognac flavoring subdued. This is a topped Margate and age has muted the Latakia and Orientals. Very smooth, but if you want more flavor, smoke it while a little fresher.
**Pre-Butera Penzance-What can you say, very nice. The youngest Penzance I have tried was 8 years old that I can think of. I was gifted a sample early on but I don't know what the age on it was so since I am old and can't remember to wake up in the morning, my thoughts are on aged tobacco. While medium in strenght, a lot goes on here with flavors changing all the time. People hoard this because it's good, and it is.
**Butera Pelican-This is marked 08/2014 so I take this to be the new stuff. A decent medium balkan blend. Kinda a dry smoke without any sweetness I could discern. The Latakia and Orientals are present to me in equal amounts but I could not pick up the VA. Reminded me of Tashkent. If you run across a tin, go for it but no hurry.
**H & H Lakeland Brickle-Since they do not make this anymore and the package is date 07/2012, I was expecting athe Lakeland tonquin bean soapiness. Not so as the crumble cake was quite dry and that soapiness and floral notes were not there. The smoke was medium and in my eyes average, maybe I am missing the Lakeland hit.
**Paul Olsen's My Own Blend-Livgarde-Another medium blend that to me was just OK at best. I had to look this up and there it was, that Burley rearing it's head again. Try this if you like Burley, if not don't.
**Paul Olsen's My Own Blend-King Frederick-This was to me a medium smoke and not full in a strict sense. There was a very nice smoky and tangy smell. It's slightly sweet with a nice balance of to me Oriental and Latakia. A very nice blend although a bit boring. If you get to try this please do so. I am an English/Balkan fan and this is nice but a cellar candidate, not really.
Woodsroad, I see you note about ST blends and I did a review on them here but since there were no comments on that thread I am posting it here:
Let me start by saying thanks to all involved in this endeavor, great job guys.
As a note I have been smoking a pipe for a year now after moving from cigars, but I still smoke them on occasion, golfing etc. and my impressions are from a new piper's perspective. I am not now nor have I ever been great at explaining flavors and the small nuances of blends. I know when I really like something, could take it or leave it and just don't like it
So for the reviews. I smoked all of the blends in a taster cob and a large bowl Ardor. They all were to me made with very good quality tobacco. The burns was effortless, very good smoke volume and burned to an ash taking into consideration the cobs, since the air hole is above the bottom of the pipe. I was pleased with them all in that respect and none of them bit me and I am a bit fast at times on the draw. I also note that the large bowl pipe made a big difference in tasting the blends, it was easier for me to pick out the subtle difference in the blends as to tobacco characteristics.
John Cotton's #1-This was a mild smoke to say the least. I picked out the Oriental right away with just a slight sour note which I like. I love Latakia and it was there but way in the background. There was an ever so slight sweetness but I found the blend to be dry and what I like to call mouth feel was not there. Heartier blends give me that feeling. All in all I liked this blend although very mild. My first thought on smoking this was it's refreshing. A nice subtle Oriental forward blend that a new guy can use to get a feel for Oriental's.
John Cotton's #1 and 2-This blend basically reminded me of JC-1 just stronger. Now they were not the same blend and there were some differences such a mouth feel and less dry. Now here while the oriental was clearly there the smoky Latakia was way more present and I love Latakia. Can anyone see where this will be going on the other blends. This was a nice medium smoke where all of the components make an entrance and exit at times. I found this to be interesting and enjoyable.
John Cotton's Smyrna-Well things are getting better with this blend, it's getting to steak time. This was a much richer blend and I would use the word savory. Tasty, sour, sweet, smokey, rich, very good silky mouth feel and a very good after taste. We are cooking now.
War Horse-Well someone turned the stove off on this one, no longer cooking for me. This review lacks some specifics and now I hate to rain on the parade but this blend did nothing for me. I must really be sensitive to Burley and I could tell it was Burley as soon as I smelled it. Now I normally like a earthy taste in my cigars and I thought I could maybe handle this but the Burley overwhelmed this blend. There was spice, there was strength to me in the plus side of medium and the dark fired added to this. The nic hit is also noticeable as compared to the other blends and is medium at best but it would be wise to eat something first. I greatly dislike cigars with cameroon leaf and I am clearly not a fan of Burley forward blends. If you hide the Burley than maybe I could have liked this. I don't care for Stonehaven for the same reason and I do not seek it out, nor will I this blend. Quality product, of course, Russ was involved. If you really like Burley forward and I mean forward blends, this is for you. Burley lovers, Enjoy
Bengal Slices-The best for last. One word-Outstanding! This is it, it's my Penzance. The blends crumble cake presentation and it's quality are superb. I rubbed it out, let it dry for a an hour and did a medium fill. Burn and smoke volume was great. My previous love was Gaslight and with this one, who knows and I can't wait to see how this ages. Latakia lovers rejoice. This has it all, spice, smoke, richness, sweetness, oriental sour note, mouth feel and I don't know what else to say. This is the Filet Mignon of these blends for me. Spice the steak up, throw it on the grill, cook to medium rare, slice it and add a good hearty Merlot and you got Bengal Slices. It was to me the best of the 5 and a definite cellar addition.
So all in all a great experience in trying each of these. If I had a $100.00 TAD budget this would be how I spend it if the tins were $10.00 each:
JC 1-$10.00, JC 1&2-$20.00, JC Smyrna-$20.00, Bengal Slices $50.00 and I would raise the TAD budget to $120.00 and make the Bengal Slices $70.00.
Now I did try the Bengal Slices, JC 1 & 2 and War Horse again. The Bengal Slices are what can I say, outstanding and I will be cellaring for sure in a nice quantity(bulk maybe?). I want to like the War Horse, I really do but it's just not to be. In some future year when my ability to taste different flavors becomes more refined, I will revisit this. The JC 1&2 is right up my alley as it was when I first tried it. I liked the refreshing, tangy and sparkling Orientals, the latakia to which I am addicted and just a really good blend, to cellar a few tins for sure.
So chop, chop and gets these out, we are waiting. LOL
Well off to try some more.