Would You Rather - Pipe/Tobacco Edition

[Dshift]

Ok this is a three-parter..
1. If you had to choose, would you rather smoke one pipe(I mean a specific model and brand), but different tobaccos, for the rest of your life, or would you rather smoke just one tobacco but switch out pipes?

2. If you had to choose Option 1, which pipe would you choose?

3. If you had to choose Option 2, which tobacco would you choose?

 

[Dshift]

Here are my answers:
1. I would definitely choose one pipe with different tobaccos.

2. Group 3 or 4 Dunhill Root Briar 3/4108 Spigot

3. DTM Bill Bailey's Balkan

 

[Dshift]

Here are my answers:
1. I would definitely choose one pipe with different tobaccos.

2. Group 3 or 4 Dunhill Root Briar 3/4108 Spigot

3. DTM Bill Bailey's Balkan

If anyone has the pipe please let me know, since it IS my Holy Grail.

 

[Goblin_Walrus]

Ok this is a three-parter..
1. If you had to choose, would you rather smoke one pipe(I mean a specific model and brand), but different tobaccos, for the rest of your life, or would you rather smoke just one tobacco but switch out pipes?

2. If you had to choose Option 1, which pipe would you choose?

3. If you had to choose Option 2, which tobacco would you choose?

1. I would choose one pipe/many tobacco.

2. If I had to smoke one pipe forever, it would probably be a Peterson 106 billiard.

3. If I had to only smoke one tobacco forever, I suppose it would be Haunted Bookshop Cake.

I will be interested to return to this thread after a few years to see if I agree with myself still!

 

[Dshift]

1. I would choose one pipe/many tobacco.

2. If I had to smoke one pipe forever, it would probably be a Peterson 106 billiard.

3. If I had to only smoke one tobacco forever, I suppose it would be Haunted Bookshop Cake.

I will be interested to return to this thread after a few years to see if I agree with myself still!

I have yet to try haunted bookshop cake...

 

[Goblin_Walrus]

I have yet to try haunted bookshop cake...

Well! I have yet to try Bill Bailey’s Balkan! I have a tin waiting for me to try at some point. I will have to crack it open and give it a shot here soon.

 

[Brad H]

The answer is always Mac Baren plumcake no matter the question.

 

[Goblin_Walrus]

The answer is always Mac Baren plumcake no matter the question.

Another one I have never tried, and at this point I probably won’t get the chance! Oh well. I’ve heard wonderful things!

 

[Dshift]

Well! I have yet to try Bill Bailey’s Balkan! I have a tin waiting for me to try at some point. I will have to crack it open and give it a shot here soon.

Please let me know how amazing you think this tobacco is and how it's way better than anything you've ever tried I will return the favor with the cake

 

[Dshift]

Another one I have never tried, and at this point I probably won’t get the chance! Oh well. I’ve heard wonderful things!

Why is it discontinued in the US?

 

[Goblin_Walrus]

Why is it discontinued in the US?

Yeah it is I am pretty sure. One of many such beloved Mac Baren blens

 

[hoosierpipeguy]

I would choose one tobacco but I could easily go either way. If one pipe, it would be my Altinok Meer. If one tobacco, no brainer, Sir John's Flake Virginia.

 

[didimauw]

Option 1.

The pipe is a peterson 314 system standard.

In the early process of working on this IRL as we speak.

 

[warren]

Easy simple questions.

Three Star Blue.

One of any of my faithful meers.

 

[Sig]

One pipe for sure.
Peterson System 315XL.
If I had to choose one tobacco, MacBaren Virginia #1.

And im ready.
Ive got the pipe and about 10 pounds of VA #1.

 

[Dshift]

Option 1.

The pipe is a peterson 314 system standard.

In the early process of working on this IRL as we speak.

Why a standard and not a better grade? Just curious.

 

[woodsroad]

One pipe, a Stanwell 63 of any variety.

If one tobacco, Blackpool or Margate.
Cheater would be a mix of Blackpool, Kingsbridge and Latakia.

Screw it. I couldn’t survive on just one blend.

 

[PaulRVA]

For me it would be multiple pipes and 1 Tobacco
I can get used to a blend and keep that blend going forever if Wanted.
This is also why Cigarette Companies would do 3 pack deals and that’s because studies show after 3 packs your acclimated to them and will continue smoking the same thing more often than not.
The Tobacco choice for me would be a VaPer and most likely Escudo, Peterson Deluxe Navy Rolls or C&D Exclusive.

 

[Mikepiper]

I have a Former egg that it is an absolute dream to smoke. Multiple blends would be my choice, with that pipe. If I had to choose one blend instead, as of today it would be Quiet Nights, unless I could choose a discontinued blend (similar to being offered a conversation with anyone in history, living or dead), and then it would be Penzance. I’m sure all will be different in 5 years, so great question!

 

[sablebrush52]

I’d rather quit pipe smoking.