Would You Rather - Pipe/Tobacco Edition

[PaulRVA]

This.

I’ve done it with a Pete 309 and only Capstan Blue averaging 3 bowls a day for 9 months in a Desert.
I could easily do it again!
I only flip/flop blends out of boredom really and have found that sticking with just one works if it’s a good one.

 

[Brad H]

I’ve done it with a Pete 309 and only Capstan Blue averaging 3 bowls a day for 9 months in a Desert.
I could easily do it again!
I only flip/flop blends out of boredom really and have found that sticking with just one works if it’s a good one.

I have 3 Peterson 309 pipes I smoke routinely. Usually smoke all 3 each day. Great pipe to use. I may even buy another to add it into the rotation, like to let the pipes rest after each smoke.

But the answer remains the same. Mac Baren Plumcake.

 

[Pipeandapencil]

All my roads seem to be moving this way anyway which is one pipe one tobacco (Escudo in a Pete Rathbone). That's where I'm at now, I'm sure it will change. Too much variety makes me anxious and unable to enjoy what I have sometimes. If I knew it was just one tobacco, I could really learn to love it well.

 

[Hutch Piper]

One pipe (MM Country Gentleman) and one tobacco (Sir Walter Raleigh - the old kind, not the new STG kind doused in vinegar).

 

[Arkansas Paul]

Worth noting that I have eaten the same breakfast and lunch for years in various stretches.

Consistently, I live by consistency so I find the thought not too crazy for me.

World would be a hell of a place if we all thought the same way wouldn't it?

 

[Brad H]

World would be a hell of a place if we all thought the same way wouldn't it?

I often times disagree with myself so no.

 

[JOHN72]

One pipe: Charles Towne Cobbler MM. Various tobaccos: Mac Baren Navy Flake, HH Pure Virginia, Cornell & Diehl Yorktown.

 

[fireground_piper]

World would be a hell of a place if we all thought the same way wouldn't it?

I’m not really sure what that means.

 

[Arkansas Paul]

It means it would be really boring.

 

[Simmerdown☕️]

I could smoke just Haunted Bookshop and that’s all.

However, I’d prefer my IMP Meer and variety in …too many delicious Virginias and VaPers out there. ️

 

[blueeyedogre]

Ok this is a three-parter..
1. If you had to choose, would you rather smoke one pipe(I mean a specific model and brand), but different tobaccos, for the rest of your life, or would you rather smoke just one tobacco but switch out pipes?

2. If you had to choose Option 1, which pipe would you choose?

3. If you had to choose Option 2, which tobacco would you choose?

1. One tobacco and switch out pipes
2. Eric Paulson Devil Ance
3. Lane's BL/WB Burley Light

 

[Brad H]

I have rethought my previous answer to this OP……
The answer remains, plumcake.

 

[RPK]

My Peterson Red Spigot 80’s with acrylic fishtail stem and Lane’s BCA or RLP-6.

 

[Waning Embers]

Worth noting that I have eaten the same breakfast and lunch for years in various stretches.

Consistently, I live by consistency so I find the thought not too crazy for me.

Same I could easily live on cheeseburgers with fried eggs on them with chili fries for every meal.

 

[Servant King]

Same I could easily live on cheeseburgers with fried eggs on them with chili fries for every meal.

Not me. Wifey would find my....errr....room note to be "less than tolerable."

 

[Waning Embers]

Not me. Wifey would find my....errr....room note to be "less than tolerable."

I break down nearly everything I eat due to an overactive thyroid. Very little bloat or waste. I have to eat very high calorie foods.

 

[damacene]

I would choose one pipe: Dunhill 4103 Straight Billiard, preferable sandblast.

If I had to choose one tobacco it would be My Mixture 965.

80% of all pipes of tobacco I smoke is My Mixture 965 in a Dunhill Group 4 billiard.

 

[HeavyLeadBelly]

One pipe. Dr. Grabow bent bulldog.

 

[Christos D. Tsatsaronis]

One pipe: MM Country Gentleman.

 

[Lumbridge]

1: One pipe with any tobacco, no doubt about it. I think I'd be fine with that.

2: Missouri Meerschaum bent hardwood Diplomat

3: Because Newminster 400 is gone now, probably Carter Hall. Neither are extremely exciting, but they're always good. Anything would get old after a while.

As infrequently as I smoke, I could live with one pipe and one blend if I had no other options.