Approximately, for how long will the tobacco be secure in rectangle Samuel Gawith tins?
Months, years?
Months, years?
Last edited:
Longevity Of Samuel Gawith Tins?
- Thread starter autumnfog
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Some with lesser faith than me in the rectangle tins will suggest putting them in jars. And, I am not going to argue with that.
I however have had dozens of tins for approximately 7 years, and they are fine. I go through occasionally and try to pull the lids off by hand. A sealed tin will NOT pull apart by hand,. so feel free to give it a good pull.
I can not predict the future, but I will most likely have them smoked in a few more years. I am not worried, but I do check them occasionally.
I however have had dozens of tins for approximately 7 years, and they are fine. I go through occasionally and try to pull the lids off by hand. A sealed tin will NOT pull apart by hand,. so feel free to give it a good pull.
I can not predict the future, but I will most likely have them smoked in a few more years. I am not worried, but I do check them occasionally.
I know some how have had them for years with no issue, and some whose tin fell right out of the lid from a fresh order right out of the box. The handful I had, Iv opened and jarred because I don’t feel like checking on them.
i usually vaccum seal the rectrangular tins
I can’t answer with certainty how long SG tins will last, but I can testify to having many 8-12 year old tins of SG St. James Flake and FVF that are doing just fine.
I personally prefer to leave tobaccos in there original tins and have multiple tins that are 10,15 to 20+ years old and generally I’ve had very few issues.
In my experience the idea of tins being a poor means of storing tobaccos is over-hyped. Once in a while a tin will fail much like the cork on an occasional bottle of wine will fail. It happens, but rarely if stored correctly.
So, I don't have to open my wines as I buy them and store them in quart jars?
It happens often enough that even the apostle of keeping it in the tin, Greg Pease, changed his stance on it several years ago. He's a long term cellarer, with tins that go back many years, and as he put it, "found a number of disappointments in my cellar". So he changed his recommendation to jarring for the long run.
I have tins that have lasted more than ten years, but even after 8 it begins to get dodgy, and the odds that the tin will fail increases with time. And why should anyone be surprised at this? These weren't intended for long term storage. Pressure seals on a rectangular tin do not have equally distributed pressure and are leaking from the get go.
Got any doubts about that? Fill a tupperware with tins and seal down the top. Then give it a couple of weeks. Do this with Virginias in one container and English in another. After a couple of weeks lean over the container, pop the top, and take a sniff. You'll smell the Virginias and their toppings. Pop the top with the English blends. You'll smell the Latakia and orientals. Your tins are slowly leaking from the day they're made. It's only a matter of time until they fail to hold a seal, and the difference that they hold up can be a minute variation in the seal at the start.
Aside from that, tins can be reliable for 8 or so years and then start to go.
I'm not arguing against what you've said, Sable....
but @glpease ...
If tins fail so often, why not sell your blends as bulks? Why keep selling us inferior packaging?
If you smell the contents, the seal is compromised.
More money to be had with tins and cellaring isn't a manufacturer's primary concern. Their products are made for immediate consumption.
I know, I know, but Greg promotes cellaring and changing the tins to jars once you get them. Why not just sell us the tobacco for twice as much as other bulks and spare us the process of having to rejar them? It seems like he invests a lot into going against his suggestions.
?
I just cellar because I'm a cheap ass and am trying to stay ahead of higher taxes.
the only thing i can add is there's that paper cardboard with their logo on it within the inner
and I'm assuming paper can absorb and dry the moisture
and I'm assuming paper can absorb and dry the moisture
I seal all my tins in mylar bags as tobacco is expensive in the UK and compared to what the bags cost it's well worth the outlay.
You're not cheap you're prudent. As well as saving money I know you have many blends that are no longer available and would cost a small fortune on the secondary market.?
My only tins that let off aroma were by bobs chocolate flake and squadron leader which are also the only SG/GH blends I keep around.
Another reason why I didn’t bother leaving them be and jarred them.
Unlike Greg, I have absolute confidence in current C&D tins. I ain't going to transfer their contents to jars.
Wait until they turn round shaped and explode.
Just a week or so ago I opened a tin of Squadron Leader that I had ordered about a year ago - the vacuum seal was completely gone, And the tobacco was pretty dry. I have several other G&H rectangular tins I need to check, and jar...
