Why go with a copy when you can get an original? I have a IM Corona Old boy as well as a few older Rollagas by Dunhill. Both are great lighters. The magie looks like a copy of a Dunhill?
If you are set on the Dunhill style, buy an OLD Dunhill. They are super simple to keep running and built to last generations.
2 things you need to know:
1. Dunhills are not designed as pipe lighters although they work fine. They used to make a conversion but are no longer available.
2. an OLD Rollagas is worth 4 new versions as they are much better built.
And all that being said, I use my IM Corona Old Boy more than any other of my fancy lighters, but in the Man Cave I use a trusty and reliable soft flamed Bic....
6 for 3.99 at Walgreens