I probably won't bother calling C&D for a replacement, but thanks for the advice Onizuka. If I had ordered more than one ounce I might make the effort, so I will remember that option in the future.
Bob - You're probably right that I might like it more if I smoked more of it. That is what happened with the Westminster that I tried. But like I said, I'm pretty sure I got a bad batch of this tobacco, so smoking more of it would probably not make a difference in this case.
Thanks for all the advice eveyone. I appreciate it.