Reviewing my list ... I stand by it but if I had to go to the "deserted island" I would grab the Erica System XL hand made and the additional 9mm military mount stem and would also grab my Barontini Gran duc 203 both of which are the finest smoothest smoking pipes I have. Always good smokes never a bad one.Erica (Pete 2nd) System XL Hand Made with orific mil stem
Erica System 302 with orific mil stem
Irish Seconds XL339S
Savinelli 2614 KS
Vauen Olaf 4873 bent egg (current workhorse)
Algerian Sitter (Believed to be J.Waille hand cut)
The rest are excellent but those two are "perfect" for me so far.