25 years of marriage is now under my belt. I have smoked for 34 yrs now but 15 on the pipe and the last full year on the pipe only. While kids were growing up I smoked outdoors or in the porch. Kids are now gone and I smoke in the room with computer. There are certain tobacco's my wife finds strong so I limit those to when she is at work. She is very happy that I gave up the cigs and tolerates the pipe. I know she would like me to quit completely but she would never push it, as I would not as well if the role were reversed. What in Blue Blazes makes one spouse think they can dictate to the other what they can or cannot do? And what is wrong with the mind set of the spouse that is being "Bullied"! Yes, I said it. It is a form of bullying regardless what you may use for an arguement. Now, if it comes down to a health issue, that is completely different, but otherwise, it is bullying. My opinion would be, "There is the door, I can use it or you can, makes no difference"! Let the door knob hit you where the good Lord split you.