As a member of CigarGeeks.com I can strongly recommend that site. There are currently 30700+ cigar reviews, and there are currently 46700+ cigars listed in their database. There are 860+ Geek Critiques where 4-6 members all review the same cigar at the same time and submit their reviews. Its interesting to see how the reviews are the same and differ on certain cigars when doing the Geek Critiques. I would say it's the most extensive cigar website on the internet. Now not all the reviews are solid, as you'll get some typical short Cigar Aficionado style reviews, but there are many detailed reviews as well. I've submitted 191 reviews, and all good reads if I do say so myself