Who Is Your Favorite Pipe Tobacco Blender?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

shikano53

Lifer
May 26, 2015
2,170
8,922
Well, Mike and I have been pipe smoking buds on here since we kind of both started pipe smoking about fifteen years ago. We generally keep in touch a few times a week via Meet. He does blend his own tobacco for His own personal consumption and his process is quite interesting, at least to me looking in from the outside.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wyfbane

John Brandt

Might Stick Around
Aug 25, 2020
88
540
63
Fall River MA
@John Brandt - Wilke

I could name some others (like whomever blends Arrowhead for Paul's Pipe Shop, and whomever blends for Boswell's are up there for me, and I love Three Star Blue) but I like a lot of different blends and many from the sources above, but I go with the blender of my favorites and a couple of his are at the very top of my list, tons right behind.
Thanks glad you enjoy the blends
 

LongIslandPiper

Can't Leave
Nov 8, 2022
329
1,503
Who is your favorite pipe tobacco blender, and why? Here are a few in no particular order:

GL Pease
Jeremy Reeves of Cornell & Diehl
Steve Willett of LJ Peretti
Ernie Q. of Watch City
Ken Byron of Ken Byron Ventures
Per Jensen
Russ Ouellette
Jon David Cole & Quinn Crawford of The Country Squire
Almost identical list except Jon David Cole from TCS is higher up on mine and after Russ Ouellette
I have Emerson Southern Forged
 

boston

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 27, 2018
618
1,436
Boston
Craig T. and Greg P. were the first guys I knew in the business. Both knew their stuff, and loved both their blends. Night Train and Old Hollywood from Craig, and Abingdon and Samara from Greg are examples. They both did Tribute, which I recall was Greg's recipe from "fools cap". I purchased a lot of that and I'm it was very fine...but lost most of it to rust and mold. It was the thought on that one, families of freedom got the proceeds.

Sick Silverman of Chief Catoonah had some of my favorites. McClelland came later for me and they made amazing blends. Now the living guys, still Greg of course, and Ernie Q are the only guys I know anymore. I do like Gawith and I like all the Sunbear versions from Jeremy Reeves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerry

boston

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 27, 2018
618
1,436
Boston
View attachment 371230
Rus blending John Cotton prototypes, 8-15
I remember that contest. A recreation right and the judging was at the Chicago show? I connected Dick Silverman with Craig Tarler because Dick wanted to be in the contest and wanted to consult with Craig on something...stoving maybe...I forget now. But anyway I think Dick came in first. I have a few of those tins.

Unless I'm wrong....and it was another contest and blend recreation...😐
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerry

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
14,322
28,394
SE PA USA
I remember that contest. A recreation right and the judging was at the Chicago show? I connected Dick Silverman with Craig Tarler because Dick wanted to be in the contest and wanted to consult with Craig on something...stoving maybe...I forget now. But anyway I think Dick came in first. I have a few of those tins.

Unless I'm wrong....and it was another contest and blend recreation...😐
Nope.
Russ was blending the prototypes of the John Cotton’s and War Horse tobaccos that Standard Tobacco debuted at the show. Not for a contest.
 

boston

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 27, 2018
618
1,436
Boston
Nope.
Russ was blending the prototypes of the John Cotton’s and War Horse tobaccos that Standard Tobacco debuted at the show. Not for a contest.
Got my stories mixed up I guess....need to check the tins. I thought there was a contest to see who most accurately recreated blend . Thanks.
 

EchoPlex

Starting to Get Obsessed
Jun 9, 2023
141
996
One of my current favorites (and probably relatively unknown) is a micro-batch blender named Big John who runs Niall of Nine. He uses rare and hyper-aged blending tobaccos to create some incredible micro-batch blends. Really looking forward to "Dead Gods", which seems very much like a tribute to McClelland and uses all vintage leaf which was then pressed/married for a year. So far everything he has released has been wonderful, intriguing, and contemplative stuff.
 

Searing75

Lurker
Mar 10, 2025
6
5
One of my current favorites (and probably relatively unknown) is a micro-batch blender named Big John who runs Niall of Nine. He uses rare and hyper-aged blending tobaccos to create some incredible micro-batch blends. Really looking forward to "Dead Gods", which seems very much like a tribute to McClelland and uses all vintage leaf which was then pressed/married for a year. So far everything he has released has been wonderful, intriguing, and contemplative stuff.
Can’t seem to find this for sale online? Where do you purchase?
 

CurlingWisps

Might Stick Around
Jan 16, 2025
67
129
Tried so many sine I started about a few years ago. I seem to have settled on GL Pease blends. They seem a lot more sophisticated than most. Current favourite… Regent Flake.
 

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
2,062
11,686
54
Western NY
I probably like Per Jensen blends the most overall. Meaning, he doesn't have any blends I don't like.
Craig Tarler and Jeremy over at C&D are great.
Russ Ouellette has many great blends. And of course Mike McNeil was a legend.
GLP has many decent blends.