Which no longer produced tobacco blend do you or will you miss the most?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

gnarlybriar

Might Stick Around
Jun 11, 2009
79
46
75
Chesterfield, VA
With so many blends not being produced, which ones do you miss the most. For me it is Edgeworth Ready Rubbed and Hines Mixture. I still have a few ounces of Hines Mixture and probably 12 oz. of Edgeworth Ready Rubbed Match. Unfortunately, once they are smoked there is no more stocking up.
 

gnarlybriar

Might Stick Around
Jun 11, 2009
79
46
75
Chesterfield, VA
State Express London Mixture, Bell’s Three Nuns, Sobranie 759, Copes and A & C Petersen Escudo, Savinelli Doblone d’Oro as it was originally formulated, HH Arcadian Perique, HU Director’s Cut as it was originally formulated, HU Makhuwa as it was originally formulated, GL Pease Renaissance, McClelland 5100, 2015, 2010, Grand Orientals, and SO MANY others…
thank you for naming my favourite 2010 - I thought i was the only one.....smoking a precious bowl tonight!
 

boston

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 27, 2018
621
1,471
Boston
The blends from Chief Catoonah and Steven Books.
I used to work at Chief Catoonah before Dick Silverman purchased it. Place was owned by Jim Cannitelli. I packed pipe tobacco in plastic containers on Saturdays when I was 14 or 15 for $25 a day. Blend 16 smelled the best. Years later I enjoy Bailey's. I stocked that in my cellar and still have some. Highland Blackwatch (I think) was a good Cavendish. Tobacco was different then.

I miss (or will) frog on log. And, frankly, many blends made 10 years ago that are not the same now. Escudo used to be better. Veermaster used to be better. Even 965 used to be better. Ennerdale had more flowers, and 1792 had more tonquin. So it goes...
 

filmguerilla

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 17, 2022
582
3,857
Memphis, Tennessee
I don't feel like I've lost anything that I couldn't find a replacement for. I thought it would be bad without London Mixture, but GLP Westminster has it covered. I wasn't a big McC or Sutliff fan so I'm good with the tins still in the cellar. Truth be told, I'd be good moving forward with just Pease, Peretti, and Gawith blends.
 

pitchfork

Lifer
May 25, 2012
4,057
698
Virginias from McClelland. There was nothing else like them when they were in production. And there probably won't be anything like them ever again.

Matured VA No. 22 was and their Blakeney's Tawny Flake were two of my favorites. And Christmas Cheer.

Tudor Castle, a VA, Perique, Oriental blend, was also out of this world.
 

IrishBadger

Starting to Get Obsessed
Nov 12, 2025
105
1,188
64
Central Missouri
Virginias from McClelland. There was nothing else like them when they were in production. And there probably won't be anything like them ever again.

Matured VA No. 22 was and their Blakeney's Tawny Flake were two of my favorites. And Christmas Cheer.

Tudor Castle, a VA, Perique, Oriental blend, was also out of this world.
I will agree 100%! Va 27 was my morning smoke and VA 24 was my evening. In between enjoyed Blackwoods flake or one of the Royal Cajuns. During colder months there was Samovar, Grand Orientals and Black Shag. Such a loss when they closed.