You have to use the tools that work for you. I wouldn't put too much into Amazon reviews for most items. A lot of people seem to have unrealistic expectations. If you're curious you should try one, if only to satisfy the curiosity. Nothing too crazy, maybe something like a Lamy Safari. Some people start with those and end up staying with them, even after buying more expensive pens. Fountain pens can be a bit fussy, but nothing extraordinarily so. The majority of my pens I just fill up and don't have to think about anything until it's time to refill or clean it. However, paper does matter, especially with a broader nib or wetter ink. Noodler's makes an ink called X-Feather which works well on most cheaper paper. Whatever you decide, from the photos you provided, what you're using now is definitely working for you!