When I lived in Connecticut it was Chief Catoonah tobacconist in Ridgefield. Got my first job there when I was 14 back in the 70's. Worked every Saturday for $25, cleaning shop and weighing and packing tobacco in tuna for the next week's sales. My first pipe was a basket bulldog, and the owner at the time (Jim Cannatelli) let me try Blackwatch, a black cav. I was a kid and it never became a fav. Many years later when Dick Silverman owned the place I tried I found Baily's Blend. That did become a fav and I still have some. Dick passed and the shop is gone. Now here in Massachusetts...
Tried Peretti a few times over the years and I understand they know tobacco too, but the place never had enuf warmth and appeal for me to bother going into Boston and finding Parking. 20 some years ago I did enjoy David P. Erlich in their shop by the park before it closed. Still have some DPE from that time but it was never a fav for me.
Today I enjoy going to Watch City from time to time. My son and I visit Ernie, and my favorite blend of his is Rythm & Blues. He knows tobacco, knows how to source good base tobacco and blend it, and knows alot of the people from the hobby that I know (and knew) and he is a good host.