I do not associate it with Hardcastle, Parker or Britannia, for starters, though I don't know those pipes historically. Barlings and Comoys I don't know.
The easier question to answer might be which makers did not use those stain colors. I have seen those stains on pipes made by Comoy's, Barling's, (real) Ben Wade, Hardcastle, Civic, and many lesser known manufacturers.
Good info, I haven't seen many of those with a deep red to maroon stain. Red undertones, yes, but not that rich burgundy of the older Dunhill, although I know others must have used similar stains. Do you have any pictures?
Doc
Les Wood (Ferndown) had a smooth, oxblood-mahogany series. It was called REO.
Here's an example:
https://winstonspipeandcigar.com/products/ferndown-les-wood-reo-bent-bulldog-silver-estate-pipe
Had a "London" stamped no-name pipe in a deep reddish brown stain, but I don't know the maker. It was a trim tapered straight billiard, very pretty, but developed a crack at the joint of the shank and the bowl. Gave it to a friend who wanted pipes for atmosphere (former Lucky Strike addict).
Perfection was a walnut type stain with a walnut background stain I think. The 'intensity of any finish was the amount of background stain and stripping that of and how many top coat stains are applied etc.
The four main stains that charatan used was dark green for the 'black' background, walnut, P.O.Red and Orange
The Distinction was a burnt-in walnut background with a light orange top coat.
Thank you Ken for invaluable information!!!
I guess I have mainly Specials, Belvedere/Perfection and several Distinction and an After Hours or two. I like the flat saddle stems the best [X]
I really like the After Hours series. It is made from a material called Catalin. My favourite grade at the moment is a very full grained (straight grain) in a Distinction finish.
I just remembered that we used to make an orange S grade finish when I worked at James Upshall in the 1980s. I must have loved that finish in those days as well!!!