Occasional cuban cigar smoker here, I have a question (arm raised) want to buy some New World cigars where should I start?
Caveat: I usually smoke Havanas when I'm smoking a cigar, and have found over the years that when I'm not, I don't generally favor Nicaraguan or Honduran tobacco, though cigars from those countries sell very well. My recommendations revolve around Dominican tobacco as I feel they offer a comparable depth of flavor and age well:
Arturo Fuente. Almost all of them age as well as Havanas, but, obviously, the flavor is different, a different terroir if you will. Each of the lines are a variation on a theme, ranging from mild Gran Reserva line to the powerhouse that is the Opus X and all of its spinoffs (Angel's Share, Don Arturo, and Anejo are all worth sampling, if available). The 858 are the classic Fuente that have been sold for decades. Later additions, such as the Hemingway and Don Carlos lines, are worth a gander, and can sometimes be had at a good price online.
La Flor Dominicans are usually much stronger, but mellow with age.
La Aurora is the oldest manufacturer still in operation in the DR. The Preferidos line is very good and frequently available at a good price at online auction.
Macanudo Cafe are some of the best-selling cigars in the world. I panned them at first as I dove into the world of boutique releases and preferred stronger cigars at the time. I recently came full circle and now enjoy the hell out of these as they are very reliable, rich, and complex.
Happy hunting!